What is a section 44 report?
A section 44 report is a formal report by an officer, usually from the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), alleging that a permanent resident or foreign national may be inadmissible to Canada. It is made under section 44(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.
The report is an important enforcement step, but it is an allegation, not a final decision. It is reviewed by a Minister’s delegate, who decides whether anything further should happen. A report can concern any ground of inadmissibility:
- Criminality or serious criminality
- Misrepresentation
- Organized criminality
- Security
- Human or international rights violations
- Non-compliance, such as an overstay or unauthorized work or study
- Inadmissible family members
- Other grounds, including the residency obligation for permanent residents
Here are the typical situations we handle:
- Permanent residents with a criminal conviction in Canada
- Allegations of misrepresentation in an earlier application
- People out of status or alleged to have worked without authorization
- Permanent residents alleged not to meet the residency obligation
- Security, organized criminality and human rights allegations
- Call-in notices for an interview about a possible report
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
How the process can begin
A section 44 report usually follows something that brings a person to CBSA’s attention. It can arise after:
- A criminal charge or conviction
- Information received by CBSA
- An immigration application
- An examination at a port of entry
- A compliance investigation
- An allegation of misrepresentation
- A call-in notice or interview
- A review of a permanent resident’s status
- An investigation into unauthorized work or an overstay
Often the first sign is a letter asking you to attend an interview. See CBSA interviews and call-in notices.
The process at a glance
Something brings you to CBSA’s attention: a conviction, an application, an investigation or a border examination.
An officer writes a report setting out the ground of inadmissibility and the facts relied on.
A more senior officer reviews the report, and any submissions, and decides what happens next.
The report is not pursued, or is sent back for more investigation.
The delegate makes a removal order where the law allows, or refers the case to the Immigration Division for a hearing.
See removal and deportation for what follows.
The Minister has to prove the allegation before an independent tribunal.
The Minister’s delegate review
If the officer believes the report is well founded, it goes to a Minister’s delegate, usually a more senior CBSA officer. Depending on your status and the ground alleged, the delegate can:
- Make the removal order directly. This applies in some cases, for example a permanent resident whose only issue is the residency obligation, and foreign nationals in situations set out in the Regulations, such as many non-compliance cases.
- Refer the report to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing. This is the route for most other cases, including criminality for permanent residents.
For misrepresentation, the delegate does not make the removal order. The matter is referred to the Immigration Division.
The interview with the delegate
Where the delegate decides the case directly, you are usually called to an informal interview. The officer often gives you the report, one or two pages setting out the section of the Act and the facts relied on, and asks whether the facts are accurate.
You do not have to agree with the report. Read the facts carefully before you confirm or sign anything. If something is wrong or missing, say so. Having a lawyer with you can help.
The steps of this interview, and what happens after a removal order, are set out on our removal and deportation page.
What can happen after a report
Depending on your status and the ground alleged, a report may:
- Not be pursued
- Be returned for further investigation
- Be resolved through another process set out in the law
- Be referred to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing
- Result in a removal order, where the law allows the delegate to make one
- Lead to other enforcement steps, such as conditions or detention
If a removal order is made, some people can appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, which can consider humanitarian reasons. Others can only apply for judicial review in the Federal Court.
A report is not a removal order. A permanent resident keeps their status, with full rights, until a removal order is made and comes into force.
Can submissions be made?
In many cases, yes. Before a decision is made, your lawyer can provide written submissions to the officer or the delegate. These can address the facts, the law, and the reasons why the report should not go further.
Depending on the case, submissions may address:
- The offence or conduct alleged, and its circumstances
- Your age when you became a permanent resident
- How long you have lived in Canada
- Your family responsibilities, including children
- Your establishment: work, home, community
- Rehabilitation, and your criminal history as a whole
- Your cooperation with the authorities, and remorse where relevant
- The hardship that removal would cause
How much weight these factors carry depends on the current law, the allegation, your status and the decision being made. Officers have only limited discretion not to pursue a report where the facts appear to be made out, and that discretion is generally wider for permanent residents.
This is often the earliest point to change the outcome. Careful, well-supported submissions at the report stage can sometimes mean the matter goes no further.
Evidence that may help
What helps depends on the allegation. Evidence can include:
- Your full immigration history and records
- Court and police documents, and proof that a sentence was completed
- Evidence about whether the facts alleged are accurate
- Foreign and Canadian legal materials
- Rehabilitation evidence
- Medical evidence
- Family documents, and evidence about children
- Employment and business records
- Evidence of community involvement
- Evidence of hardship
- Evidence explaining any non-compliance
- Affidavits about your conduct and cooperation
Common kinds of reports
Reports involving criminality
Where the allegation is criminality, the analysis may require:
- Confirming the offence and how the case was resolved
- Working out which immigration provision applies
- Looking at the maximum possible sentence
- Deciding whether the allegation is criminality or serious criminality
- Considering appeal rights
- Assessing the effect on permanent resident status
- Considering rehabilitation and discretionary submissions
Reports involving misrepresentation
The allegations may concern:
- False or withheld information
- Earlier marriages or relationships
- Children or family members not declared
- Employment or education
- Criminal history
- Identity
- Immigration history
- The conduct of a representative
A response usually needs a careful timeline, the original forms, supporting records, and an explanation of how the information was prepared and submitted. See misrepresentation.
Other reports
See non-compliance, security, organized criminality and inadmissible family members.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in section 44 reports. What is put before the decision-maker early can shape what happens next, so we start early and prepare carefully. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
- Reviewing the call-in notice or report
- Identifying exactly what inadmissibility is alleged, and what has to be proved
- Obtaining your immigration records
- Preparing you for the CBSA interview, and attending it with you where permitted
- Correcting factual errors and misunderstandings
- Gathering the supporting evidence
- Preparing legal and discretionary submissions
- Assessing the risk of referral to the Immigration Division
- Preparing for an admissibility hearing if the matter is referred
- Advising on appeal and judicial review options
We know how frightening it is to be told you may not be allowed to stay in Canada. We tell you candidly where you stand, and we make sure you understand each step.
What to bring to your consultation
- The report, call-in notice or any letter from CBSA
- Court records and police documents, if any
- Your passport, permanent resident card and immigration documents
- Your earlier immigration applications and decisions
- Proof of your family ties, work and time in Canada
- Any evidence of rehabilitation, if criminality is alleged
Questions
Does a section 44 report mean I will be deported?
Not automatically. It is an allegation and a step in a process. What follows depends on the ground, the evidence, your status and the process that applies.
Do I lose my permanent residence when the report is written?
No. A permanent resident keeps their status until a removal order is made and comes into force.
Do I have to agree with the report?
No. If the facts are wrong or incomplete, say so. Read everything carefully before you confirm or sign it.
Can CBSA issue a removal order?
In some cases. A Minister’s delegate can make the removal order for certain grounds and people. Other cases are referred to the Immigration Division for a hearing.
Can I make submissions before a decision?
Often, yes. Written submissions on the facts, the law and your personal circumstances can sometimes mean the report goes no further.
Should I attend a CBSA interview without legal advice?
Given what is at stake, it is wise to get advice first and decide whether you should be represented.
How much will this cost?
You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.
Related

CBSA Interviews & Call-In Notices
CBSA has asked you to come in for an interview. What it may be about, how to prepare, and what can follow.

Admissibility Hearings
Representation at Immigration Division hearings about whether you can stay in Canada.

Removal & Deportation
What happens after a removal order, and the steps that may still be open to you.