What is non-compliance?
Non-compliance means breaking a rule of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act or its Regulations. A foreign national who does so can be found inadmissible to Canada under section 41 of the Act, and that can affect both their ability to stay and their ability to apply for anything in the future.
The three most common situations are:
- Overstaying: staying in Canada after your status has run out
- Studying without authorization: studying without a valid study permit, or outside its conditions
- Working without authorization: working without a work permit, or outside its conditions
Here are the typical situations we handle:
- Visitors, workers and students whose status has expired
- Students who changed schools, took a break, or dropped below full-time
- Workers who changed employers, locations or jobs without a new permit
- People who worked while waiting for a permit, or worked more hours than allowed
- People facing a CBSA interview or a section 44 report for non-compliance
- People whose past non-compliance is now blocking a new application
The law in brief
- Section 41 of the Act makes a person inadmissible for failing to comply with the Act. For a foreign national, it covers any act or omission that goes against a provision of the Act.
- Section 29(2) requires a temporary resident to comply with the conditions of their stay and to leave by the end of the period authorized. Overstays are usually alleged under this section.
- Section 30(1) says a foreign national may not work or study in Canada unless authorized.
- Section 41(b) covers permanent residents who do not meet the residency obligation. See residency obligation appeals.
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
Overstaying
Every visitor record, work permit and study permit has an end date. If you stay in Canada past that date without having applied to extend it, you are out of status. This is the most common form of non-compliance.
It often happens through no bad intent: a permit expired while an employer was preparing paperwork, an application was refused, or the dates were simply missed. The law treats it as non-compliance all the same.
Applied before your status expired? If you applied to extend your status before it ran out, you can generally remain in Canada under the same conditions while the application is decided. This is called maintained status. It ends if the application is refused. There are exceptions, so get advice before relying on maintained status.
Studying without authorization
Studying without authorization can mean:
- Studying without a study permit, or after your study permit has expired
- Studying at a school other than the one your permit allows
- Not studying full-time when your permit requires it
- Taking a leave or a break that goes beyond what the rules allow, or not actively pursuing your studies
A breach of these conditions can put at risk your ability to remain in Canada, to keep studying here, and in some cases to return to Canada later. See study permits.
Working without authorization
Working without authorization can mean:
- Working without any work permit
- Working for an employer other than the one named on a closed work permit
- Working in a different location, region or job than the permit allows
- Working more hours than a student is permitted to work off campus
What counts as “work”?
The definition is broader than many people expect. Under the Regulations, work is an activity for which wages are paid or commission is earned, or an activity that competes directly with Canadian citizens or permanent residents in the Canadian labour market. That means unpaid work can still be work. Volunteering in a role that would normally be a paid job, or an unpaid “trial” period, can count.
What non-compliance can lead to
- You may not be able to apply for new status. Being out of status, or having worked or studied without authorization, can make you ineligible for a new visitor record, work permit, study permit, or permanent residence from inside Canada. For work and study permits, there can be a waiting period of six months after the unauthorized work or study ends.
- CBSA can take enforcement action. CBSA can write a section 44 report. In many non-compliance cases, a CBSA officer can make the removal order directly, without a hearing. See removal and deportation.
- It can follow you. Past non-compliance can be raised in future applications, and has to be disclosed truthfully. Hiding it can lead to a finding of misrepresentation, which is far more serious.
The process at a glance
Status runs out, or work or study happens without authorization.
At the border, at an interview, or through information shared with CBSA. This can lead to a section 44 report and a removal order.
You want to extend, change or regularize your status, and the non-compliance stands in the way.
Restoration within 90 days, or a new application once you are eligible.
A discretionary permit where there is a compelling reason to stay despite the non-compliance.
Options to come back into compliance
What is available depends on what happened, when, and what you are applying for. The main options are:
- Restoration of status. If your status ended within the last 90 days, you may be able to apply to restore it, as long as you meet the requirements and complied with your other conditions. While the application is pending, you cannot work or study. Restoration is generally not available if you lost status by working or studying without any authorization.
- A new application, once eligible. Where a waiting period applies, the timing and the explanation of what happened are key.
- A temporary resident permit. A discretionary permit allowing you to stay despite the non-compliance, where your need to be in Canada is compelling.
- Leaving and applying from outside Canada, in some cases. This needs careful planning, because leaving can affect other options.
Some permanent residence programs, and humanitarian and compassionate applications, may also be open to people out of status.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in non-compliance matters. The earlier we act, the more options remain open. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
We have two priorities:
- Bring you back into complianceAs quickly as possible, because the longer it goes on, the fewer options remain.
- With as little disruption as possibleTo your life in Canada, your work or studies, and any application already in process.
Non-compliance is rarely as simple as it looks on paper. Through our work on complex applications and inadmissibility, we know how much turns on the exact facts: when status ended, what was applied for and when, what activity took place, and why. We set those facts out in detail, with the evidence to support them, so the officer sees the true extent of the non-compliance, and nothing more.
From there, we choose the path that gives you the strongest position, whether that is restoring your status, a new application, a temporary resident permit, or responding to CBSA. If CBSA is already involved, we prepare you for interviews and represent you through the process.
We know this is extremely stressful for you and your family. We tell you candidly where you stand, and we make sure you understand each step.
What to bring to your consultation
- Your passport, and every visitor record, work permit and study permit you have held
- Any applications you submitted, with proof of the date they were sent
- Letters from IRCC or CBSA
- Employment records: offer letters, pay stubs, and dates of each job
- School records: enrolment letters, transcripts and any leave approvals
- A timeline of your time in Canada, as best you can
Questions
I overstayed by a few days. Is it too late?
Possibly not. If it has been less than 90 days, restoration may be available if you meet the requirements. Get advice quickly.
I applied for an extension before my permit expired. Am I out of status?
Generally not. You can usually stay under the same conditions while the application is decided. If it is refused, that changes, so act quickly.
I volunteered without pay. Is that working without authorization?
It can be. If the activity competes with jobs that Canadians or permanent residents could do, it may count as work even if you were not paid.
Will non-compliance affect my future applications?
It can. It may need to be disclosed and explained, and some applications have waiting periods. Get advice before you apply.
Will CBSA deport me?
Not automatically. CBSA can take enforcement action, but there may be options to come back into compliance first. If CBSA has contacted you, speak to a lawyer before the interview.
How much will this cost?
You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.
Related

Temporary Resident Permits
A discretionary permit to enter or stay in Canada despite an inadmissibility.

Section 44 Reports
An officer has reported that you may be inadmissible to Canada. What the report means, what can follow, and how to respond.

Removal & Deportation
What happens after a removal order, and the steps that may still be open to you.