Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Permanent Residency/Humanitarian and Compassionate Applications

Last updated

Permanent Residency

Humanitarian and Compassionate Applications

A discretionary request to stay in Canada, or to waive a requirement, where the circumstances justify an exception.

What is a humanitarian and compassionate application?

Section 25 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act allows the Minister to grant permanent residence, or to waive a requirement of the law, where humanitarian and compassionate considerations justify it, taking into account the best interests of a child directly affected. It is a discretionary request. It is often a last resort for people who have no other way to become permanent residents.

Here are the typical situations we handle:

  • People who have built a life in Canada but have no other route to status
  • Families with children in Canada
  • Family separation, including family members who cannot qualify under the usual categories
  • People who are inadmissible, for example for medical reasons, and need a waiver
  • Failed refugee claimants, once the waiting period has passed
  • Applications made from outside Canada together with another permanent residence application

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

Who can apply, and what can be waived

A person in Canada can apply, and the Minister must consider their circumstances. A person outside Canada can also ask, but the Minister may, rather than must, consider it, and the request must be made together with a permanent residence application on one of the existing forms, such as a family or refugee application.

The scope of the discretion is wide. In general, almost any requirement of the Act or the Regulations can be waived, for example the definition of a family class member or medical inadmissibility. There are limits. In general, an H&C request cannot be made by:

  • People found inadmissible for security, human or international rights violations, or organized criminality
  • People with a refugee claim that is pending or has been found ineligible
  • People whose refugee claim was refused, abandoned or withdrawn in the last 12 months, unless the best interests of a child under 18 would be adversely affected. A medical exemption may also apply.
  • Designated foreign nationals, until five years have passed

What the officer considers

Officers look at the whole picture. The three main considerations, amongst many, are:

  • Hardship if you have to leave Canada, including discrimination or violence in your home country, or being unable to get the medical care or work you need there
  • Establishment in Canada: how long you have lived here, your work, your community, your family and your finances
  • The best interests of any child directly affected, looked at in light of each child’s age, needs and maturity, and their emotional, social, cultural and physical welfare

The Supreme Court of Canada has said that this is an equitable remedy and must be assessed as a whole. Officers should not apply rigid rules. Hardship that every person in your situation would feel is usually not enough. The evidence needs to be personal and specific to you and your family. An H&C application is also not the place to argue risk of persecution or torture. That is assessed in a refugee claim or a PRRA.

The process, start to finish

1
Choose the route

We decide whether to apply from inside or outside Canada, what the underlying application is, and what needs to be waived. A request from inside Canada usually goes with an application for permanent residence.

2
Prepare and file

We prepare the forms, your sworn statement, the legal submissions and the evidence. The checklist from IRCC is a guide, not a full list of what should be included.

Stage 1: approval in principle
Approved in principle

You can apply for permanent residence from within Canada. Removal is generally stayed, and you may be able to apply for a work permit, a study permit and provincial health coverage.

Refused

The request is refused. See what can follow below.

3
Stage 2: admissibility checks

Medical and criminal checks are done for you and your family. Any inadmissibility that you were not exempted from must still be addressed.

Final decision
Approved

You pay the right of permanent residence fee, attend the confirmation and become a permanent resident.

Refused

You may have options. See below.

Weighing the decision

Why people choose it

  • It can be the only option for people who do not qualify elsewhere
  • It can waive inadmissibility and other requirements
  • Once the request is approved in principle, there may be a stay of removal and access to a work permit and health coverage

The limits

  • It is discretionary, and nothing guarantees an outcome
  • There is no right of appeal
  • Processing times are long and unpredictable
  • Filing does not stop removal

Do not forget: filing an H&C application does not automatically stop a removal. If you have a removal date, you may also need a deferral request or a stay motion.

Evidence and submissions

H&C applications are won on evidence that is personal, specific and connected to the legal test. Every application should include a sworn statement from the applicant. It is generally presumed to be true unless there is a reason to doubt it, so it must be accurate and consistent with everything else you file.

Evidence that may help
  • Support letters from family, friends, employers, schools, clergy and doctors
  • Medical, psychological and police reports
  • Records from work, school, banks and taxes
  • Evidence about the children: school records, reports, letters from teachers and doctors
  • Evidence of community involvement and volunteer work
  • Country information, where it relates to your personal situation
  • Evidence of the hardship you would face if you had to leave

An officer cannot ignore a medical or psychological opinion only because it relies on what you told the professional. Evidence that is general or does not link to the facts of your case, or that is exaggerated, does not help. We always address the weak points of the case directly and honestly.

Common pitfalls

  • Not enough evidence, or evidence that is not tied to your facts
  • Assuming that the officer will see the hardship without being shown
  • Hardship that is general rather than personal
  • Writing that does not persuade

After the decision

  • If approved: you receive instructions for the next steps, including medical and background checks.
  • If refused: you can ask for reconsideration, but this is only done in exceptional circumstances, such as new evidence or an error. You can also reapply with new evidence, since there is no bar. And you can ask the Federal Court to review the decision, within 15 days for applications arising from inside Canada, or 60 days for applications arising from outside Canada. See judicial review of permanent residence refusals.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in humanitarian and compassionate applications. These succeed or fail on the evidence and on how well it is tied to the legal test, so we plan the application carefully. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

  • Assessing whether an H&C application is the right route, and what the alternatives are
  • Counselling you honestly about the strengths and weaknesses of your case
  • Identifying the evidence and helping you collect it, including reports and support letters
  • Preparing your sworn statement and the legal submissions
  • Preparing applications from inside and outside Canada
  • Addressing inadmissibility and requests for waivers
  • Coordinating the application with any removal proceedings
  • Advising on reconsideration, reapplication or judicial review if refused

What to bring to your consultation

  • Your passport and immigration documents, and any decisions you have received
  • Documents about your time in Canada: leases, work records, tax returns, school records
  • Documents about your family, including your children
  • Medical or psychological records, if relevant
  • Support letters from people who know you
  • Any removal order or notice you have received

Questions

Does applying stop my removal?

No, not by itself. A deferral request or stay may be needed. A lawyer reviews your situation.

Can I apply from outside Canada?

Yes, in some cases, together with another permanent residence application.

Can I work while the application is pending?

Possibly, once it has been approved in principle and a work permit is obtained.

I have Canadian children. Will I be approved?

Having children is an important factor, but it is not enough by itself, and no one can promise an outcome. The best interests of the children must be shown with evidence.

Is an H&C application the same as a PRRA?

No. A PRRA assesses risk. An H&C application looks at hardship, establishment and the best interests of children.

What if it is refused?

There may be options, including reconsideration, a new application with new evidence, and judicial review. The deadlines are short.

How much will this cost?

You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about humanitarian and compassionate applications.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook