Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Federal Court/Stay of Removal Motions

Last updated

Federal Court

Stay of Removal Motions

Urgent Federal Court motions to pause a scheduled removal from Canada.

What a stay is

A stay motion asks the Federal Court to prevent removal temporarily while an underlying proceeding before the Federal Court is decided.

A stay is different from a deferral. A deferral is asked of CBSA. When a deferral is refused, that decision can be judicially reviewed at the Federal Court, but a judicial review does not automatically stop removal. A stay motion therefore needs to be brought. See deferral of removal requests.

Separately, a stay motion can also be brought on an existing pending judicial review application.

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

What the Court looks at

On a stay motion, the Court is not deciding whether you should be allowed to remain in Canada indefinitely. Instead, it applies a very strict three-part test, and each part needs its own evidence and legal argument.

1. A serious issue to be tried

There must be a genuine issue in the underlying judicial review application before the Court, for example an unreasonable decision, procedural unfairness, failure to consider important evidence or an incorrect legal test.

2. Irreparable harm

Even if you show a serious issue, the Court must also be satisfied that you would suffer irreparable harm if removal is not stayed. This is typically harm that cannot be adequately repaired at a later date, such as exposure to serious risk, interruption of urgent medical treatment, serious consequences for a child, or family separation with effects that cannot later be remedied. There is no finite list of situations, and the person bringing the motion has the onus of satisfying the Court that irreparable harm would arise. General hardship or inconvenience is usually not enough. The harm must be concrete, supported by evidence and connected to the removal.

3. Balance of convenience

The Court weighs your circumstances against the public interest in enforcing immigration law. Factors can include how serious and immediate the harm is, your conduct and compliance with immigration requirements, timing, and the practical effect of a short postponement.

How it works

  1. The first signA call-in notice, a pre-removal interview, or a removal date. This is when we start preparing, even before a decision is made on a deferral request.
  2. Choosing the routeWe decide whether the motion will be brought in an existing judicial review or in a new one, for example a challenge to a refused deferral. Sometimes both are needed at once. We follow the Court’s practice guidelines, which are always the starting point.
  3. Building the motionWe prepare your affidavit and supporting evidence, the motion record and written arguments, and give notice to the Court and to the Department of Justice as the rules require.
  4. The hearingThe motion is often heard on short notice, sometimes by video or telephone. We present the case and answer the judge’s questions.
  5. The resultIf a stay is granted, removal is paused, usually until the underlying case is decided. If it is refused, removal can go ahead. In very urgent situations, a short interim stay may be requested to give the Court time to hear the motion.

Timing and last-minute motions

Timing is often the hardest part. A motion brought at the last minute may be questioned, so we are ready to explain why it was not brought sooner. We try to start early and to avoid urgent motions where we can, because more time means a better record and a stronger presentation.

Where the underlying case is a deferral refusal

When CBSA refuses a deferral request, we may challenge that refusal in the Federal Court and ask for a stay at the same time. When CBSA does not respond, the choice between treating the silence as a refusal and asking the Court to require a decision depends on how close removal is.

Evidence for a stay motion

The evidence depends on your specific situation, the facts and the grounds on which you are seeking a stay, including the irreparable harm you are advancing. Generally speaking, the following documents may be relevant.

  • Your affidavit, and affidavits from family members
  • Medical or psychological reports
  • Evidence about children
  • Country condition evidence, where risk is alleged
  • The removal direction and CBSA correspondence
  • The underlying immigration decision
  • Proof that a judicial review has been filed

Page limits apply to motion materials, so the evidence has to be selective and well organised.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in stay motions before the Federal Court. These are urgent matters that need immediate and meticulous legal attention. Where necessary, we assign more than one lawyer and a whole legal team, because a stay motion is won not only on good legal arguments but, more importantly, on the strength of the evidence. We go through every page and every detail to put forward the best case we can within a very short time.

Stay motions are difficult to win, so every small thing can make the difference. Our team knows what is needed, has the experience to put it together, and has the people to make sure that, even though the matter is urgent, it gets the attention it deserves. In practice, that means:

  • Reviewing the removal and the underlying decision straight away
  • Identifying the serious issue
  • Preparing affidavits and exhibits and obtaining supporting evidence
  • Preparing the motion record and legal arguments
  • Communicating with the Department of Justice
  • Appearing at the stay hearing
  • Continuing the underlying judicial review

What to bring to your consultation

  • The removal order, removal direction and any CBSA letters
  • The decision you are challenging and any Federal Court documents
  • Your passport and travel documents
  • Medical records or evidence about children, if relevant
  • Proof of any pending application

Questions

Do I need to report for removal while the motion is pending?

Unless a stay is granted, the removal arrangements remain in place.

Is a deferral request the same thing?

No. A deferral is asked of CBSA; a stay is ordered by the Court.

How long can I stay if my stay motion is granted?

It depends on the underlying judicial review application. A stay is typically in place until that judicial review application is decided.

Do I need to speak in court?

No. In a stay motion, typically all of the evidence is provided through written affidavits, and the submissions are made through the motion record by your lawyer.

I have Canadian children. Would they still remove me from Canada?

Having Canadian family members may be a compelling or relevant factor, but it is not sufficient on its own to stop your removal or to grant a stay motion.

Will the stay motion be decided before I am removed?

That is the whole goal: to have the Court decide the motion and stop your removal. The Court’s ability to do that depends in large part on how timely the documents are filed. If you do not act quickly, the Court may refuse to hear the motion.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about stay of removal motions.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook