What is an admissibility hearing?
An admissibility hearing decides whether a permanent resident or foreign national in Canada is inadmissible, and so can be ordered to leave. It is held before the Immigration Division (ID), an independent tribunal of the Immigration and Refugee Board. The Minister, represented by CBSA’s counsel, has to prove the allegation. If it is proven, the member makes a removal order.
The hearing comes after a CBSA officer writes an inadmissibility report and the report is referred to the ID. That earlier stage is explained on our section 44 reports page. This page picks up once your case has been referred.
Here are the typical situations we handle:
- Criminality, including permanent residents with a conviction
- Misrepresentation
- Non-compliance, including the residency obligation
- Organized criminality, security, and human or international rights violations
- Health, financial and family-member grounds
- Hearings held together with a detention review
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
The process at a glance
CBSA sends the referral and the Minister’s disclosure. You may then hear nothing for weeks or months.
The member checks that both sides are ready, narrows the issues, and usually sets the hearing date.
Legal arguments, the evidence to support them, and preparing you to testify.
Your testimony and any witnesses, then legal submissions from each side.
The proceedings end and there is no removal order.
The member makes the removal order that applies.
Some people can appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, which can consider humanitarian reasons.
Others can only apply for judicial review in the Federal Court.
Receiving the referral package
It usually starts with a package from CBSA saying that your matter has been referred to the Immigration Division for an admissibility hearing. After that, you may not hear anything for weeks or even months.
The package is the Minister’s referral. It contains the disclosure the Minister mainly relies on to show that you are inadmissible, such as:
- The inadmissibility report and the referral
- The section of the Act you are alleged to have breached
- Court records, application forms or other documents behind the allegation
- The officer’s notes or narrative
- Proof of your status in Canada
This package gives us what we need to work with. We read the section of the Act first, because it tells us exactly what the Minister has to prove. Then we go through the facts with you. Are they true? Where is the Minister’s case strong, where is it weak, and how should you position yourself?
An honest look at the case comes first. Sometimes there is a real defence. Sometimes the result is close to certain, and the better strategy is to concede the allegation and put the effort into an appeal and the humanitarian case. We cannot argue something we know to be untrue, so we ask you to be completely honest with us, and we tell you directly what we think.
A report is an allegation, not a decision. A permanent resident keeps their status, with full rights, until a removal order is made and comes into force.
Pre-hearing conferences at the Immigration Division
In most cases, the Immigration Division holds a pre-hearing conference before the hearing itself. Its purpose is to make sure both parties are ready to proceed. The member will ask the Minister’s counsel and you, or your lawyer:
- Whether anything stands in the way of going ahead
- Whether the issues can be narrowed
- Whether both sides can meet their disclosure obligations
- Whether either side is calling witnesses, and especially expert witnesses
The answers help the member decide how long the hearing should be: half a day, a full day, or several days. Most of the time, the member sets the hearing date at the end of the conference. It is usually a few weeks or a few months away, depending on everyone’s availability.
Have a lawyer before the conference if you can. If you come without one, the member will urge you to find and retain counsel, but may not give you time to do so before setting the hearing date. Once a date is set, it is difficult to change without a justifiable reason.
Preparing for the hearing
After reviewing the Minister’s disclosure, you need to know exactly how you are going to answer the case. Preparation comes in three parts:
- The legal argumentsWhat the Minister must prove, and where the law or the facts fall short.
- The evidenceThe documents and witnesses needed to support those arguments, filed on time and in the right form.
- Preparing you to testifyThis is the most important part, because your own evidence usually carries the most weight.
In nearly every case, the person concerned has to testify. Your credibility is central. Your evidence will be the most important in the hearing, and the member will scrutinize it closely. You need to know which questions are relevant, what the Minister’s counsel is likely to ask you, what the member may want to hear from you, and how to testify at a hearing like this.
How to testify, and the most common mistakes
There is a particular way to give evidence that lets your credibility come through and gives the member the answers they need. The most common mistakes we see are:
- Not answering the question that was asked. Answering a different question, or talking around it.
- Not saying “I don’t know” or “I don’t remember”. If that is the truth, it is the right answer.
- Guessing or speculating. A guess that turns out to be wrong can damage everything else you say.
- Not knowing your own evidence. Every form, letter and document on file can be put to you.
- Talking too much. Offering information you were not asked for, or filling silences.
More tips for the hearing day
- Keep answers short when speaking through an interpreter, and do not talk over anyone.
- Tell the member if the interpretation seems wrong, or if you need a break, water or medication.
- It is normal to become emotional. You can ask for a moment.
- Sleep well, eat beforehand, and for a video hearing, test your device and connection early.
The hearing day
Most admissibility hearings now take place remotely, by video. Usually present are:
- The member, who manages the hearing and makes the decision
- The Minister’s counsel, who represents the Minister and tries to satisfy the member that you are inadmissible
- Your lawyer, if you are represented
- An interpreter, if you need one. Their only job is to interpret accurately.
Opening the hearing
The member starts with opening remarks. They explain what the proceeding is about, make sure everyone is on the same page and has the disclosure, and check that nothing procedural prevents the hearing from starting.
The evidence
Once everyone is ready, you are sworn in. Because the Minister carries the burden of proof, the Minister’s counsel questions you first and can ask about anything relevant. Your lawyer then questions you, to cover areas that were missed or were not clear. The member can step in at any point to clarify or ask more questions. After you finish, any other witnesses called by either side testify, and they can be questioned by the other side too.
Submissions
After all the evidence is in, the parties make their legal arguments. No new evidence can be given at this point. The Minister’s counsel goes first, then you or your lawyer, and the Minister has a final right of reply. The member may ask either side to clarify the law or the facts.
Simpler cases are often argued orally at the end of the hearing. In more complex cases, such as organized criminality, security or human rights allegations, submissions may be made in writing afterward.
The decision
In simpler cases, the member may decide at the end of the hearing. In complex cases, the member often reserves the decision. You can expect it anywhere from a few weeks to a few months later, depending on the complexity, and it will be in writing.
- Not inadmissible. The proceedings end. The Minister can challenge the decision.
- Inadmissible. The member makes the removal order that applies, which may be an exclusion order, a departure order or a deportation order.
If a removal order is made, what happens next depends on your status and the ground. Some permanent residents and protected persons can appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division, which can consider humanitarian reasons. Others, for example people found inadmissible for serious criminality, security, human rights violations or organized criminality, have no appeal and can only apply for judicial review in the Federal Court.
The law in brief
- No humanitarian discretion at the ID. The member decides only whether the facts are true and meet the legal test. Humanitarian reasons can be raised at the IAD, where an appeal is available.
- Appeal rights. Section 63 of the Act sets out who can appeal to the IAD, and section 64 removes the appeal in some cases, including serious criminality punished in Canada by six months or more.
- When an order takes effect. A removal order generally comes into force when it is made if there is no appeal, when the appeal period ends, or when an appeal is finally decided. A permanent resident loses status at that point.
Your rights at the hearing
- To be told the date, time and place, and the case against you, with full details of the allegations
- Enough time to prepare, including a reasonable postponement under the rules
- To present evidence and call witnesses, and to question the Minister’s witnesses
- To a competent interpreter
- To a designated representative, if you are under 18 or cannot understand the proceedings
The Immigration Division rules in brief
- Disclosure. Documents are numbered, on paper of a set size or electronic equivalents, with a list. In a hearing held together with a detention review, documents must be provided as soon as possible, and in others at least five days before.
- Translation. A document in another language needs a translation and a translator’s declaration.
- Witnesses. The other side and the ID must be told in writing who will testify, for what, how long, and by what means. An expert must provide a signed summary and their qualifications.
- Changing the date. An application to change the date or time is considered on several factors, such as timing, preparation, whether you have counsel and earlier delays.
- Everything else. A party who wants the ID to decide a matter generally has to apply in writing.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in admissibility hearings. The outcome often turns on the evidence and how you give it, so we prepare both the file and you carefully. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
- Reviewing the referral package and the Minister’s disclosure, and telling you honestly where the case stands
- Advising whether to defend the allegation or concede it and focus on an appeal
- Representing you at the pre-hearing conference
- Building the legal arguments and gathering the evidence to support them
- Preparing you to testify, including practice with the questions the Minister’s counsel is likely to ask
- Presenting your case at the hearing and making the submissions, orally or in writing
- Planning ahead for an appeal, judicial review or a stay of removal if the decision goes against you
What to bring to your consultation
- The referral package and every letter from CBSA or the Immigration Division
- The inadmissibility report, if you have it separately
- Your passport, permanent resident card and immigration documents
- Court records or police documents, if relevant
- Copies of past immigration applications and forms
- Documents and contact details for any witnesses
Questions
How long until my hearing?
After the referral, you may not hear anything for weeks or months. A hearing date is usually set at the pre-hearing conference, often a few weeks or months later.
Do I have to testify?
In nearly all cases, yes. Your testimony is usually the most important evidence, so we prepare you carefully.
Can I change the hearing date?
Only with a justifiable reason. Once a date is set, the Immigration Division expects it to go ahead, which is why it helps to have a lawyer before the pre-hearing conference.
Do I lose my permanent residence when the report is written?
No. A permanent resident keeps their status until a removal order is made and comes into force.
Can I raise humanitarian reasons at the hearing?
No. The ID cannot consider them. They can be raised at the Immigration Appeal Division where an appeal is available.
Should I just concede?
Sometimes. If the allegation is clearly true, it may be better to focus on the appeal. We tell you honestly what we think.
What if I miss the hearing?
The ID can proceed without you. If there is a reason you cannot attend, tell us at once so we can ask for a change.
How much will this cost?
You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.
Related

Section 44 Reports
An officer has reported that you may be inadmissible to Canada. What the report means, what can follow, and how to respond.

Removal Order Appeals
Appealing a removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division.

Judicial Review of IRB Decisions
Federal Court review of decisions by the divisions of the Immigration and Refugee Board, including the Refugee Protection Division, Refugee Appeal Division, Immigration Division, and Immigration Appeal Division.