Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Inadmissibility/Criminal Inadmissibility

Last updated

Inadmissibility

Criminal Inadmissibility

A conviction or charge, in Canada or abroad, can affect your immigration status.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

What this is

Sections 36(1) and 36(2) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) separate serious criminality from criminality. Permanent residents can be found inadmissible for serious criminality, while foreign nationals can be affected by either. Offences committed outside Canada are compared to the closest Canadian offence.

  • Convictions in Canada or abroad, including impaired driving
  • Some pending charges or acts committed abroad
  • Possible loss of permanent resident status or refusal of entry
  • Possible deportation of a permanent resident for serious criminality

What counts as serious criminality

Under section 36(1)(a), a permanent resident or foreign national is inadmissible for having been convicted in Canada of an offence under an Act of Parliament punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment of at least 10 years, or of an offence under an Act of Parliament for which a term of imprisonment of more than six months was imposed. Section 36(1) also covers convictions and acts outside Canada.

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

How the process works for a permanent resident

The steps below describe a permanent resident who has a Canadian conviction that falls under section 36(1)(a).

1
Conviction

A conviction that falls under section 36(1)(a) can make a permanent resident inadmissible for serious criminality.

2
Section 44 report

The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) may write a report alleging serious criminality.

3
Referral to the Immigration Division

The report may be referred to an admissibility hearing. Although the Act says an officer “may” refer it, the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal have said officers have little discretion, if any, not to refer a report where the person is described by the section.

4
Admissibility hearing

A member of the Immigration Division decides whether the person is in fact inadmissible. If the statutory criteria are met, the member must issue a deportation order and has no discretion to give equitable relief.

Can the person appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD)?
Often yes

Under s.63(3), a permanent resident can appeal a removal order to the IAD, where they can ask for equitable relief.

Not if the sentence was six months or more

Under s.64(1) and (2), the appeal right is barred where the sentence imposed was six months or more.

What the IAD can do
Dismiss the appeal

The removal order becomes final and enforceable.

Allow it or stay the order

The IAD can allow the appeal or stay removal, with conditions, if humanitarian and compassionate factors justify it.

If an appeal is not available, judicial review in the Federal Court may be the remaining route. See judicial review of IRB decisions and section 44 reports.

Appeals and relief at the IAD

On appeal, the IAD first decides whether the removal order is valid in law. If it is, the IAD then decides whether there are enough humanitarian and compassionate factors to warrant special relief, looking at all the circumstances. The Federal Court has described the factors the IAD weighs, often called the Ribic factors (see Nguyen-Tran, 2010 FC 93, at para. 9):

  • The seriousness of the offence leading to the removal order
  • The possibility of rehabilitation
  • How long the person has been in Canada and how established they are
  • The family and community support available to the person
  • The family in Canada and the disruption that removal would cause
  • The hardship the person would face in their country of nationality

The first two factors carry significant weight. A further conviction, a breach of a conditional sentence or probation order, signs of a criminal lifestyle, or anything that undermines rehabilitation can seriously harm an appeal.

Stays of removal and what follows
  • Dismissal. If the IAD is not satisfied, it can dismiss the appeal and the removal order becomes final and enforceable.
  • A temporary stay. If the IAD has concerns about whether the person will comply, it can stay removal for a period, often one to three years, on conditions similar to probation. They typically include keeping the peace and being of good behaviour, making reasonable efforts to maintain full-time employment, not knowingly associating with people who have a criminal record, and reporting to CBSA.
  • A new serious conviction. Under s.68(4), if the person is convicted of another offence described in section 36(1) during the stay, the appeal is automatically dismissed.
  • Reconvening. After the stay ends, the IAD reconvenes and makes a final decision, largely on the person’s record of compliance.

Foreign nationals and other situations

Foreign nationals face different rules, which can be triggered by a wider range of offences and acts, including some outside Canada, and they generally do not have the same right of appeal as permanent residents. Rehabilitation and Temporary Resident Permits may help in some cases. See criminal rehabilitation and temporary resident permits.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in criminal inadmissibility matters. Timing with the criminal case matters, so we work with defence counsel where possible. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

We work with criminal defence counsel before a plea where possible, assess how a conviction is likely to be treated under immigration law, and represent you at CBSA interviews, admissibility hearings and appeals. Whether an appeal right exists can depend on the length of the sentence, so the sentence itself can be an immigration decision. We also prepare the humanitarian and compassionate evidence an appeal depends on, such as rehabilitation, family and community support.

What to bring to your consultation

  • Court records, charge sheets and sentencing documents
  • Police certificates
  • Your immigration documents and any CBSA letters
  • Name of your criminal lawyer, if you have one
  • Evidence of rehabilitation, employment, family and community support

Questions

Does a discharge count as a conviction?

A Canadian discharge is generally not a conviction for immigration purposes, but foreign outcomes need careful review.

Should I talk to an immigration lawyer before pleading guilty?

Yes, if you are not a Canadian citizen. The plea and sentence can change your immigration options, including whether you can appeal.

I just received a letter from CBSA saying I might be criminally inadmissible. What should I do?

Contact a lawyer immediately. You have the right to provide a response to the report. In addition to providing your own evidence, you may be able to request equitable relief based on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.

Can you provide evidence to my criminal lawyer and the court about the immigration consequences?

Yes. We regularly work with members of the defence bar and issue immigration legal opinions that are presented at the Ontario Court of Justice and Superior Court of Justice, and we comprehensively explain the legal consequences on your immigration status should you receive a conviction or receive a specific outcome or sentence.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about criminal inadmissibility.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

CallBook