What this is
Section 37 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) makes a person inadmissible for organized criminality. No criminal charge or conviction is required. The Federal Court has read the key terms broadly, so people with limited or indirect involvement can be caught.
- Alleged association with gangs or criminal networks
- Family or business ties that an officer treats as membership
- Alleged involvement in drug trafficking or money laundering
- Allegations of people smuggling or trafficking
- Permanent residents generally have no appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division on this ground.
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
Three ways a finding can be made
1. Membership in a criminal organization (s.37(1)(a))
- Membership and criminal organization are given a broad interpretation. Membership means belonging to the organization, and it can include past membership.
- Taking part in a legitimate business, knowing it is controlled by a criminal organization, can be enough.
- Formal membership is not required. Informal participation or support may be enough.
- A criminal organization is a group with some common organizational features, such as an identity, leadership, a loose hierarchy, a basic structure, or a particular territory or meeting place. No single feature is essential.
- Some Federal Court decisions import the Criminal Code definition, which requires at least three people.
- The person must know the organization is criminal in nature, but not every offence it committed. Evidence of belonging, and inferences about knowledge, can be enough.
2. Taking part in organized criminal activity (s.37(1)(a))
This branch does not require membership in an organization. A person can be found inadmissible for engaging in activities related to organized crime. Again, no formal organization is required, and three or more people acting together to further a crime may be enough.
3. Transnational crime (s.37(1)(b))
This covers activities such as people smuggling, human trafficking and money laundering in a transnational setting. Although drug trafficking is not listed in the section’s text, the Federal Court has treated it as transnational crime for this purpose.
Standard of proof and evidence
- Reasonable grounds to believe. Under s.33, this is lower than the civil standard of a balance of probabilities, but more than mere suspicion (Mugesera, 2005 SCC 40).
- Flexible evidence rules. Under s.173, the Immigration Division can rely on evidence it considers credible or trustworthy. There is no rule against hearsay, and most evidence gathered by law enforcement and put forward by the Minister is likely to be admitted.
- Charges are not decisive. Whether charges were laid, withdrawn or ended in a conviction is relevant but not determinative. Police reports can be admitted even if charges were withdrawn, if they are credible and trustworthy.
- Court records carry weight. Agreed statements of fact and a judge’s comments in conviction or sentencing records are probative and are likely to be given significant weight.
Key cases
- Chiau, 1998 CanLII 9042 and 2000 CanLII 16793: meaning of membership and criminal organization
- Sittampalam, 2006 FCA 326: past membership and organizational features
- Thanaratnam, 2005 FCA 122: participation without membership
- Saif, 2016 FC 437: the three-person requirement
- Chung, 2014 FC 16: knowledge of the criminal nature of the organization
- Gaytan, 2021 FCA 163 and Aghevli, 2017 FC 568: evidence of belonging and inferring knowledge
- Korasak, 2021 FC 1047: informal participation or support
- Wang, 2021 FC 226: engaging in organized crime activities
- Dhillon, 2012 FC 726: drug trafficking as transnational crime
- Odosashvili, 2017 FC 958 and Pascal, 2020 FC 751: charges not determinative and police reports
Citations are given for reference.
How it works
- AllegationThe concern may arise at an interview, in an application or through a CBSA investigation.
- Report and referralA section 44 report may lead to an admissibility hearing.
- HearingThe Minister must show reasonable grounds to believe the facts alleged.
- After a decisionOptions can include judicial review and, in some cases, an application for ministerial relief.
Because the standard is low, the way related criminal proceedings end can matter for immigration. Withdrawn charges help but do not close the issue, and statements of fact in a conviction can be used against someone who was only on the edge of the conduct. Anyone facing both criminal and immigration exposure should speak to an immigration lawyer early.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in organized criminality allegations. These allegations are serious and fact-heavy, so we test the evidence thoroughly. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
We test the evidence behind the allegation, including what the organization is said to be, what you knew and what you actually did. We work with criminal defence counsel where there is a related case, prepare you for interviews, and represent you at the Immigration Division and in Federal Court.
What to bring to your consultation
- Any CBSA letters, reports or interview notes
- Police or court documents, including any agreed statement of facts
- Records of employment, travel and business dealings
- Names of people who can speak to your role
Questions
Can I be found inadmissible without being convicted?
Yes. The test is reasonable grounds to believe, which is lower than the criminal standard, and charges do not have to have been laid.
Is there an appeal?
Generally not to the Immigration Appeal Division for permanent residents on this ground, so judicial review is often the main route.
Related

Admissibility Hearings
Representation at Immigration Division hearings about whether you can stay in Canada.

Section 44 Reports
An officer has reported that you may be inadmissible to Canada. What the report means, what can follow, and how to respond.

Criminal Inadmissibility
A conviction or charge, in Canada or abroad, can affect your immigration status.