Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Inadmissibility/Security Inadmissibility

Last updated

Inadmissibility

Security Inadmissibility

Security concerns, including past membership in an organization, explained plainly.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

What is security inadmissibility?

Section 34 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act makes a person inadmissible to Canada for security reasons. The law covers:

  • Espionage against Canada or contrary to Canada’s interests
  • Subversion of a government by force, and acts of subversion against a democratic government, institution or process
  • Terrorism
  • Being a danger to the security of Canada
  • Acts of violence that could endanger people in Canada
  • Being a member of an organization that there are reasonable grounds to believe engages, has engaged or will engage in any of those acts

Here are the typical situations we handle:

  • Past service in a military, police, intelligence or government organization
  • Membership in, or contact with, a political or armed group, even a limited one
  • Work or study connected to a state institution
  • Security screening that has delayed an application for years
  • A procedural fairness letter, or an interview, about a security concern
  • A refusal, or a referral to an admissibility hearing, on security grounds

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

How the law works

  • A low standard. The test is reasonable grounds to believe. That is more than suspicion but less than the usual civil standard, and it can include facts that may occur in the future and facts that arise from omissions. The usual rules of evidence do not apply, so credible and trustworthy information can be used.
  • Membership is read broadly. A person does not have to be a formal or “true” member, and the courts have not required proof that the person was complicit. The word “organization” is also read broadly, and a group can be an organization without a formal structure. Some judges have questioned how far this should go, but the broad approach still applies.
  • Espionage generally means secret or covert gathering of information for a foreign entity, or passing it on. The courts have also said that the activity must have a connection to Canada’s security. Recent decisions have taken a wide approach.
  • Subversion and terrorism are not defined in detail, and the law is still developing.

Because the law is broad, facts that seem minor can matter, and what the person actually did, and when, often decides the case.

What a finding means

A security finding can have serious effects. A person found inadmissible on these grounds generally cannot make a refugee claim to the Immigration and Refugee Board, cannot make a humanitarian and compassionate application, and cannot get refugee protection through a PRRA, although risk can still be assessed in a limited way. The main relief available is a request for ministerial relief directly to the Minister.

How security screening works

Applications are screened first by IRCC, which looks at its own records and risk indicators, and shares biometrics with the RCMP. Some applications are then sent for a more detailed security review, which involves the Canada Border Services Agency, and, where there are national security questions, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. The agencies use open sources, such as news and social media, intelligence databases and information from allied countries. CBSA then makes a recommendation to IRCC, which makes the final decision.

  • You may never see the details. Classified information is not shared with applicants or their lawyers, and a letter will not include it. This makes these cases hard to answer.
  • It can take years. Once an application goes to detailed screening, ordinary processing times no longer apply. Requests to speed it up are usually allowed only in compelling circumstances.
  • IRCC makes the decision. If it disagrees with CBSA, there is a process for consultation, but even when IRCC is satisfied, CBSA must be satisfied before a person is allowed to enter.

The process, start to finish

1
Screening

Your application or claim is screened. This can be quiet, and you may not know it is happening.

Does IRCC have a concern?
Procedural fairness letter or interview

IRCC writes to you, or calls you to an interview, to describe the concern and give you a chance to respond, usually within a set number of days. A CBSA interview is also possible.

No concern

The application continues.

2
Your response

We respond in writing or with you at an interview. This is the main opportunity to put the facts before the decision-maker.

Does IRCC maintain the concern?
Yes

The application is refused, or the matter is referred for an admissibility hearing. A second, more detailed letter is also common.

No

The application is processed further.

After a refusal or a long delay
Relief and review

Options can include ministerial relief, a Federal Court review, and, if the delay has been unreasonable, a mandamus application. See mandamus.

Other options

A temporary permit in a national interest case, or a different application.

Responding to a security letter or interview

  • Read the letter closely. It may be a general or templated allegation. We can ask for particulars, and we examine the sources cited.
  • Build a full, honest account of your history, with documents and a timeline of what you did, when, and why.
  • Use affidavits and, where helpful, expert reports, to address broad or sweeping assertions about an organization or an institution.
  • Prepare for the interview. We practise with you, play the part of a sceptical officer, take notes, and flag any problem with interpretation or with undisclosed material.
  • Expect a second round. A second letter that fixes weaknesses in the first, and discloses more, is increasingly common.
  • Be realistic about time and cost. These cases move slowly, and the law’s threshold is low and its reach broad.

We also assess your overall situation while you wait: whether your permits are expiring, whether you have visas, whether there is harm from the delay, and what the limits are of the application you are waiting on.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in security inadmissibility matters. These cases need a detailed, accurate account of your history and careful preparation. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

  • Reviewing your history and identifying what the officer may be concerned about
  • Explaining the law and the realistic risks and timelines
  • Preparing the response to a procedural fairness letter, with affidavits and expert evidence where needed
  • Preparing you for IRCC, CBSA or CSIS interviews
  • Requesting and reviewing your file through access to information requests
  • Advising on ministerial relief, a Federal Court review, and mandamus for delay
  • Coordinating with any related application, permit or claim

What to bring to your consultation

  • Military service booklets or discharge papers
  • A timeline of employment, education, service, memberships and travel
  • Any letters from IRCC or CBSA, including the procedural fairness letter
  • Your past applications and forms
  • Any information about organizations you belonged to or worked for

Questions

Does any IRGC conscription mean I am inadmissible?

Not automatically. Decision-makers look at the specific facts of the service, so careful preparation matters.

Why is my application taking so long?

Security screening can add significant delay. In some cases a mandamus application may be considered.

Can I see the evidence against me?

Not always. Classified information is generally not disclosed, though the letter should tell you enough to respond.

Can I apply on humanitarian grounds?

Generally not if you are inadmissible on security grounds. Ministerial relief is the main route.

How much will this cost?

You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about security inadmissibility.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

CallBook