Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Inadmissibility/Inadmissible Family Members

Last updated

Inadmissibility

Inadmissible Family Members

When one family member’s inadmissibility affects the rest of the family’s application or status.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

What is family-member inadmissibility?

Under Canadian immigration law, one person’s inadmissibility can extend to their family. Section 42 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act makes a foreign national inadmissible in two situations:

  • Your family member is inadmissible. This applies to an accompanying family member, and in some circumstances to one who is not coming with you.
  • You are accompanying someone who is inadmissible. For example, a spouse or child included in the application of a person found inadmissible.

Whether it applies to you depends on who the family member is, whether they are accompanying you, the ground of their inadmissibility, and what you are applying for. Protected persons are not covered by this rule.

Here are the typical situations we handle:

  • A spouse or child with a criminal record, a medical issue, or a security concern
  • A family member named in a procedural fairness letter about someone else’s inadmissibility
  • Family members facing a section 44 report because a spouse or parent is being removed
  • Families applying together for permanent residence where one person has an issue
  • Temporary residents whose spouse is alleged to be inadmissible on security grounds

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

Where it usually comes up

During a permanent residence application

An officer reviewing a permanent residence application may find that one family member is inadmissible and send a procedural fairness letter. The other family members on the application can receive one too, because the allegation against one person may make the whole family inadmissible.

When someone is facing removal

If a removal order is made against one person, CBSA may also write a section 44 report against their family members and pursue their removal on the same basis. See removal and deportation.

When you apply for permanent or temporary residence

If you apply for permanent residence, a visa, a work or study permit, or an extension, and one of your family members is inadmissible, your own application can be refused on that basis, even if you have done nothing wrong yourself.

Who counts as a family member?

For this rule, the Regulations define a family member as:

  • Your spouse or common-law partner
  • Your dependent child, or your spouse’s or partner’s dependent child
  • A dependent child of that dependent child, meaning a grandchild

A dependent child is a biological or adopted child who is either under 22 and not a spouse or common-law partner, or 22 or older and has depended substantially on the parent’s financial support since before age 22 because of a physical or mental condition.

Your parents are not your family members for this rule just because they are your parents, and a conjugal partner counts only if they qualify as a spouse or common-law partner. Exactly who is caught still depends on the type of application and on whether the person is accompanying you.

Accompanying and non-accompanying family members

An accompanying family member is coming to Canada with you, or is included in your application to stay. A non-accompanying family member is not. Leaving a family member out does not necessarily remove the risk. A non-accompanying family member can still make you inadmissible, depending on the situation.

This applies if you are a temporary resident, or are applying for temporary residence, a permanent resident visa, or to remain in Canada as a temporary or permanent resident.

Which kinds of inadmissibility matter

It depends on what you are applying for:

  • Permanent residence. Any ground of inadmissibility can be passed on through a family member, such as criminality, health, misrepresentation or security.
  • Temporary residence. If you are a temporary resident, or are applying for temporary status or to stay as a temporary resident, it is passed on only for the most serious grounds: security, human or international rights violations, sanctions, and organized criminality.

This only covers inadmissibility passed on through a family member. You can still be inadmissible on your own grounds.

The law in brief
  • Section 42(1) of the Act sets out the two routes: an inadmissible family member, or accompanying an inadmissible person.
  • Section 42(2) limits the rule for temporary residents and temporary-resident applications to sections 34 (security), 35 (human or international rights violations), 35.1 (sanctions) and 37 (organized criminality).
  • Section 1(3) of the Regulations defines “family member”, and section 2 defines “dependent child”.
  • Section 23 of the Regulations sets out when a non-accompanying family member counts.

How do you know if a family member makes you inadmissible?

There is no simple checklist. The rules are spread across several sections of the Act and the Regulations, and the answer turns on a number of factors together:

  • Who the family member is, and whether they meet the legal definition
  • Whether they are accompanying you
  • The ground of their inadmissibility, and whether it has actually been established
  • What you are applying for, and your current status in Canada

Each case needs a legal analysis of these factors before you apply or respond. A family member who seems to be a problem may not be one in law, and the reverse is also true.

Can separating or divorcing solve the problem?

A genuine separation or divorce changes who your family members are. For a non-accompanying spouse, the rule does not apply where the relationship has broken down in law or in fact.

But officers look closely at timing. If a separation or divorce appears to be only a way to get around the inadmissibility, and not genuine, it can lead to a finding of misrepresentation, which carries its own five-year bar.

It can also cause problems later. If you remarry or reconcile with the same person and want to sponsor them, officers may question whether the relationship is genuine and whether the earlier divorce was. Get advice before taking any step like this.

Options if a family member is inadmissible

Depending on the ground and the application, the options may include:

  • Challenging the finding itself. Showing that the family member is not inadmissible, or does not meet the legal definition of a family member.
  • Dealing with the family member’s own inadmissibility. For example, criminal rehabilitation for a past offence outside Canada.
  • Humanitarian and compassionate considerations for permanent residence.
  • Ministerial relief, a national interest request for certain security, human rights and organized criminality grounds.
  • A temporary resident permit for temporary entry or stay.

If a decision has already been made, an appeal or a judicial review in the Federal Court may be possible.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in matters involving inadmissible family members. One person’s issue can put the whole family at risk, so we look at the entire family’s situation from the start. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

  • Working out whether the rule applies at all: who is a family member, who is accompanying, and which ground is alleged
  • Reviewing the evidence against the family member and testing whether the inadmissibility is established
  • Responding to procedural fairness letters for every family member involved
  • Representing family members at CBSA interviews and through section 44 reports and removal
  • Advising on the risks before you apply, including what to declare
  • Preparing humanitarian, ministerial relief or temporary resident permit requests where the finding cannot be avoided

We know how stressful it is when one person’s situation puts everyone’s future in Canada in question. We tell you candidly where each family member stands, and make sure you understand each step.

What to bring to your consultation

  • Every application filed by each family member, and the list of family members declared
  • Any procedural fairness letter, refusal, call-in notice or section 44 report
  • Marriage, divorce, separation and birth certificates
  • Custody orders or agreements for any children
  • Documents about the family member’s issue, such as court records or medical reports
  • Your current permits or status documents

Questions

Whose inadmissibility can affect me?

Generally your spouse or common-law partner, your dependent children and your spouse’s dependent children, and their dependent children. It depends on the type of application and whether they are accompanying you.

My spouse is inadmissible. Can I divorce to avoid the problem?

A genuine divorce changes who your family members are. A divorce that appears to be only a way around the inadmissibility can lead to a misrepresentation finding, and can cause problems if you later want to sponsor that person.

Will my parents’ inadmissibility affect my child who is over 22?

Generally no, because a child over 22 is usually no longer a dependent child. The exception is a child who has depended on their parents since before age 22 because of a physical or mental condition.

Does it matter if my spouse is not coming to Canada with me?

It can. A non-accompanying spouse can still make you inadmissible unless the relationship has broken down. The same goes for a dependent child in your custody.

Can my family member overcome their inadmissibility?

Possibly, depending on the ground. Options can include rehabilitation, humanitarian and compassionate considerations, ministerial relief, or a temporary resident permit.

Can I just leave a family member off my application?

No. Family members generally have to be declared, even if they are not coming. Leaving them off can be misrepresentation, and an undeclared family member may later be excluded from sponsorship.

How much will this cost?

You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about inadmissible family members.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

Free calls are with one of our litigation lawyers, usually within one or two business days.

CallBook