What are abandonment and ministerial intervention?
These are two different situations, but both can change the course of a refugee claim before the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) of the Immigration and Refugee Board.
- Abandonment is when the RPD decides that you are no longer pursuing your claim, usually because you missed your hearing or did not file your Basis of Claim form on time. An abandoned claim is ended.
- Ministerial intervention is when the Minister takes part in your claim, usually because the government holds information about you that it says is adverse, and asks the RPD to refuse the claim.
Here are the typical situations we handle:
- Claimants who never received their hearing notice because their address changed
- Claims declared abandoned after a representative missed incoming mail
- Claimants called to an abandonment hearing for a late Basis of Claim form
- Claimants facing removal after their claim was declared abandoned
- Claimants who received the Minister’s notice of intent to intervene, or disclosure from the Minister
- Claimants the Minister says made an earlier refugee claim in another country
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
How a claim ends up abandoned
When you make a refugee claim, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) processes it and decides whether you are eligible. If you are, the claim is referred to the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB), which schedules your hearing.
Several months, or even years, can pass between the referral and the hearing. In that time people move and their circumstances change. Often they do not update their contact information, or they update one organization and assume that is enough for the others.
Telling one office is not enough. IRCC, the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) and the IRB each need your current contact information, most importantly your mailing address. Each has to be told separately.
When the IRB sends out the hearing notice, it goes to the old address. The claimant never receives it and misses the hearing. The panel can then declare the claim abandoned.
The abandonment (show-cause) hearing
If you miss your hearing, if you do not file your Basis of Claim form on time, or if the panel is otherwise concerned that you are abandoning your claim, it can hold a special hearing on abandonment, often called a show-cause hearing.
At this hearing, you have to show that you fully intend to go ahead with your claim, and explain why it should not be declared abandoned. Medical or other evidence explaining what happened can matter a great deal.
Attend. If you receive a notice of an abandonment hearing, attend on the date given, and get advice before you go. If you miss it, the claim can be declared abandoned at that point.
What happens when a claim is abandoned
- Your claim ends. It is treated as refused, and your file is closed.
- There is no appeal. You cannot appeal an abandoned claim to the Refugee Appeal Division.
- Removal can follow. Your removal order generally becomes enforceable, and CBSA can move ahead with your removal.
- You generally cannot make a new refugee claim in Canada.
Reopening an abandoned claim
Finding out later and explaining what happened is not enough on its own. A letter saying that your circumstances changed, or that you forgot to update your address, is generally not a sufficient reason to reopen the claim. Reopening is available only in narrow circumstances, generally where there was a failure of natural justice, and the request needs evidence that fits those grounds.
Judicial review of the abandonment decision in the Federal Court may also be possible. The deadline is 15 days for applications arising from inside Canada. See judicial review of IRB decisions.
Abandonment at a glance
IRCC finds the claim eligible and refers it to the IRB, which later schedules a hearing.
A move or a change in circumstances is not reported to every office, and the hearing notice goes astray.
The hearing is missed, or the Basis of Claim form is late, and the panel considers abandonment.
You show at the abandonment hearing that you intend to pursue the claim, and it goes ahead.
The claim ends, there is no appeal to the RAD, and the removal order can become enforceable.
An application to the RPD on the narrow grounds available, made as soon as possible.
Judicial review, a PRRA, or other applications that could allow you to stay.
How we help with abandonment
As soon as we are retained, we work through these steps:
- Deal with any enforcement firstWe check whether CBSA enforcement is imminent. If it is, the priority changes: we deal with it at once, to gain the time needed to reopen the claim. See deferral of removal and stay of removal.
- Find out exactly what happenedOften the cause is an address that was not updated. Other times it is an error by the IRB, or a representative who missed incoming correspondence.
- Apply to reopen, where possibleWe gather affidavits, supporting evidence and other documents showing your intention to pursue the claim and the specific grounds on which you may qualify for reopening, and file the application as soon as possible.
- Look at the alternativesWhere reopening is not realistic, we look at what else you may qualify for, such as a pre-removal risk assessment or another immigration application that could allow you to stay in Canada.
There can be a waiting period before a PRRA is available after an abandoned claim.
What is ministerial intervention?
In some refugee claims, the Minister decides to intervene. This usually happens when the government holds adverse information about the claimant that it says was not disclosed. The information can relate to:
- Your credibility
- Your identity
- A refugee claim you made in another country
- Other information CBSA holds about you
The Minister can also intervene on questions such as exclusion from refugee protection.
Two ways the Minister can take part
- Disclosure only. The Minister sends the adverse information to the IRB without asking to be a party to the claim.
- Intervening as a party. The Minister asks to take part in the proceeding. Minister’s counsel can then attend your hearing, question you, cross-examine you on your testimony, and make submissions to the panel on why your claim should be refused.
You usually find out through a package from the Minister: a notice of intent to intervene, or the documents being disclosed.
The Minister does not decide your claim. The Minister is seeking a particular outcome, but whether your claim is accepted or refused is decided by the RPD member hearing it.
How we help when the Minister intervenes
The Minister’s package should be reviewed in full as soon as possible. We then work through these steps:
- Review the disclosureWe work out whether the documents raise a significant or adverse issue for your claim.
- Assess the impactHow it affects your claim, and whether it undermines any of the issues the panel has to decide.
- Gather the evidenceEvidence that counters the Minister’s disclosure or position, or that properly addresses and explains it.
- Answer the Minister’s submissionsWe respond to the Minister’s arguments with counter-submissions.
- Prepare you for cross-examinationIf Minister’s counsel will attend, preparation is the most important part of the case.
- Protect your credibilitySo you remain in the strongest position for your claim to succeed.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in abandonment and ministerial intervention matters. Both can move quickly, and both can end a claim if they are not handled properly, so we act at once. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
We know how frightening it is to learn that a claim has been abandoned, or that the government is opposing it. We tell you candidly where you stand, and we make sure you understand each step.
What to bring to your consultation
- Any notice from the IRB, including a notice to appear or of an abandonment hearing
- The abandonment decision, if one was made
- The Minister’s notice of intent to intervene, and all documents disclosed
- Your Basis of Claim form and claim documents
- Proof of your addresses since you made your claim, and of any change-of-address notices you sent
- Any letters from IRCC or CBSA, including a call-in notice
- Medical or other evidence explaining a missed hearing or deadline
Questions
I moved and never received my hearing notice. Can my claim be reopened?
Possibly, but not just because you explain that you moved. Reopening is available only in narrow circumstances. Get advice immediately, especially if CBSA has contacted you.
I told IRCC my new address. Isn’t that enough?
No. IRCC, CBSA and the IRB each need your current contact information. Telling one does not update the others.
Can I appeal an abandoned claim?
No. An abandoned claim cannot be appealed to the Refugee Appeal Division. The options are reopening, judicial review, or other applications, and each depends on timing.
If the Minister intervenes, do I need to respond immediately?
It depends on the documents and what they raise. Even if you do not need to respond right away, you should start preparing your response to the Minister’s application.
If the Minister intervenes, does that mean I will lose my claim?
No. The Minister does not decide your claim. The RPD member decides whether your claim is accepted or refused, and whether to grant what the Minister is asking for.
I just received a package saying the Minister intends to intervene in my claim. What should I do?
Speak to a representative immediately. If you already have a lawyer, contact them and set up a meeting to see how it could affect your case and how to prepare. If you do not, get independent legal advice right away.
How much will this cost?
You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment. If your claim has been abandoned and CBSA is involved, call us directly.
Related

Refugee Claims & RPD Hearings
Help making a refugee claim and preparing for your RPD hearing.

PRRA, Pre-Removal Risk Assessment
Applying for protection based on risk before removal from Canada.

Stay of Removal Motions
Urgent Federal Court motions to pause a scheduled removal from Canada.

Judicial Review of IRB Decisions
Federal Court review of decisions by the divisions of the Immigration and Refugee Board, including the Refugee Protection Division, Refugee Appeal Division, Immigration Division, and Immigration Appeal Division.