Book a consultation →
Home/Practice areas/Refugee Claims & Appeals/Refugee Claims & RPD Hearings

Last updated

Refugee Claims & Appeals

Refugee Claims & RPD Hearings

Help making a refugee claim and preparing for your RPD hearing.

What the RPD decides

Canada protects people who cannot safely return to their country because they face persecution, a danger of torture, a risk to life, or a risk of cruel and unusual treatment or punishment. Genuine fear or hardship is not enough on its own. The RPD decides whether you meet the legal definition based on your circumstances, testimony and evidence.

  • Your identity and nationality
  • What happened to you and who caused or may cause harm
  • Why you were targeted
  • Whether the authorities can adequately protect you
  • Whether you could safely and reasonably live elsewhere in your country
  • Whether your conduct is consistent with a genuine fear
  • Whether any exclusion or ineligibility rule applies

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

How a claim works

Once a refugee claim is filed, several steps follow, each with its own deadline. These include the Basis of Claim form deadline, eligibility, and other disclosure if and once the claim is referred to the RPD.

  1. Making the claimFrom inside Canada or, in suitable cases, at a port of entry. Officials first decide whether the claim is eligible to be referred to the RPD. Eligibility is not acceptance of the claim.
  2. The Basis of Claim (BOC)The BOC records your identity, family, travel history and the story of why you need protection. It should be complete, accurate and consistent, and focused on the important events, people, dates and places.
  3. Gathering evidenceDocuments that support your identity, the key events and conditions in your country.
  4. Disclosure and preparationEvidence is assembled and filed under the rules and deadlines, with translations where needed. We check the BOC, forms, port of entry notes and earlier statements against each other.
  5. The hearingThe RPD member asks questions, and your lawyer can ask questions, call witnesses and make submissions.
  6. The decisionThe RPD accepts or rejects the claim. A refused claimant may have a right to appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division, or may seek judicial review in the Federal Court.
Evidence that may help
  • Passports, national identity and civil documents
  • Membership records from political, religious, student, union or community groups
  • Police reports, arrest records, court documents and complaints
  • Threats, messages, emails or social media posts
  • Photographs, video or audio
  • Medical and psychological records
  • Witness affidavits and expert reports
  • News reports and human rights documentation
  • Evidence of your activities in Canada
  • Evidence about similarly situated family members or associates

Is the claim eligible?

Before a claim reaches the RPD, an officer decides whether it is eligible to be referred. This usually happens quickly after the claim is made. Eligibility is not a decision on whether you are a refugee. It only decides whether the RPD can hear your claim.

A claim may be found ineligible, for example, if:

  • You made a previous refugee claim in Canada, whether it was refused, withdrawn, abandoned or found ineligible
  • You made a claim in another country that shares immigration information with Canada
  • You already have refugee protection in another country, or are already a protected person in Canada
  • You arrived from the United States and the Safe Third Country Agreement applies, unless an exception covers you
  • You are inadmissible for serious criminality, security, human rights violations or organized criminality
Safe Third Country Agreement exceptions

Some people who arrive from the United States can still make a claim. The exceptions include people with certain family members in Canada, unaccompanied minors, people holding certain Canadian documents, and some public interest cases. The rules are specific, so the right evidence of the family relationship or other exception matters from the start.

If the claim is found ineligible, it does not go to the RPD. You may face removal, but you may be able to apply for a pre-removal risk assessment, and an ineligibility decision can be challenged in the Federal Court within a short deadline.

The RPD hearing

An RPD hearing is less formal than a court trial but is a legal proceeding with serious consequences. The people present may include the RPD member, you, your lawyer, an interpreter, witnesses and, sometimes, a lawyer for the Minister.

The member usually controls the questioning. Topics can include identity, the chronology, your travel history, delays in leaving or claiming, return trips, whether you sought police protection, and whether you could live elsewhere in your country. You should not memorise a script. You should understand your history, review the evidence and explain events accurately in your own words.

Issues that often decide claims

Credibility

Many claims turn on credibility. A concern does not mean the RPD thinks the whole claim is invented. Concerns can come from inconsistencies, omissions, implausible evidence, conflicts between testimony and documents, differences between the BOC and port of entry records, or conduct that seems inconsistent with fear. Trauma, interpretation problems, memory and the circumstances of earlier statements can explain some discrepancies, but an explanation needs to be clear and supported where possible.

Correcting a BOC

Mistakes and omissions should not be ignored. A BOC may need amending if an important event was left out, a date or name is wrong, an interpreter or preparer made an error, or new events have happened. Raising a significant correction for the first time at the hearing can create an avoidable credibility problem.

State protection and internal flight alternative

The RPD may ask whether you sought help from the police and whether protection would realistically have been available. If you did not approach the authorities, be ready to explain why.

An internal flight alternative (IFA) is a place elsewhere in your country where the RPD thinks you could be safe and where it would be reasonable to live. The RPD asks whether you could safely relocate there and whether it would be reasonable to expect you to. Relevant matters include whether the person you fear could find you, family and community networks, language, gender identity or sexual orientation, health, religion or ethnicity, and access to housing and services.

Delay and returning to your country

The RPD may ask why you waited before leaving or claiming, why you returned after becoming afraid, or why you used or renewed your national passport. These facts do not automatically defeat a claim, but they need a careful explanation, for example improved conditions for a time, responsibilities to children, inability to travel safely, lack of money or documents, trauma or misinformation.

Medical and psychological evidence, and witnesses

Medical evidence can document injuries and ongoing effects. A psychological report can help explain trauma symptoms, memory difficulty, delayed disclosure or apparent inconsistencies. A professional report does not replace your own evidence, but it can add corroboration and context.

A witness is most helpful when they have genuine, first-hand knowledge, for example of your identity, events, threats or activities, and can explain how they know it. Evidence may be given in person, by affidavit or by another reliable form.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in refugee claims and RPD hearings. Your Basis of Claim form and evidence shape the claim, so we prepare them carefully and early. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

  • Assessing eligibility, including Safe Third Country Agreement exceptions, and possible legal issues
  • Advising on judicial review or a PRRA if the claim is found ineligible
  • Preparing or reviewing the BOC, and making corrections or amendments
  • Identifying missing evidence and reviewing earlier immigration records
  • Preparing disclosure and researching country conditions
  • Preparing you to testify, and identifying and preparing witnesses
  • Responding to credibility, state protection and IFA concerns
  • Representing you at the RPD hearing
  • Advising on the decision and any appeal or review

What to bring to your consultation

  • Your passport and any identity or travel documents
  • Any immigration forms and notes from the port of entry
  • Documents that support your story, and a list of what you could not obtain
  • Names of possible witnesses
  • Any medical or psychological records

Questions

What if my claim is found ineligible?

It will not go to the RPD. You may face removal, but you may be offered a PRRA, and the decision can be challenged in the Federal Court within a short deadline. Get advice right away.

Do I need documents to succeed?

Not every event can be documented, but claimants are generally expected to make reasonable efforts to get relevant evidence or explain why it is unavailable.

Should I memorise my BOC?

No. You should understand and review it carefully, but memorised testimony can sound unnatural and cause difficulty when questions are asked differently.

What if I do not understand the interpreter?

Say so immediately, during the hearing. Raising it later is much harder.

What if my claim is refused?

Depending on the circumstances, there may be a right of appeal to the RAD or an application for leave and judicial review. Deadlines are short, so get advice right away.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about refugee claims & rpd hearings.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook