What a RAD appeal is
A RAD appeal is not a chance to repeat your claim. It should identify material errors in the RPD’s analysis and explain why the decision should be changed or sent back for a new hearing. Not everyone has a right of appeal, so the first step is to confirm whether you do. If not, judicial review in the Federal Court may be available, with a short deadline.
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
How it works
- Get the reasons and confirm the right to appealWe review the RPD’s written reasons and confirm whether an appeal is available.
- Review the recordThe BOC, the evidence and the hearing record.
- Identify the errorsFactual, legal and fairness errors that can be raised.
- Assess new evidenceWhether anything created or obtained since the RPD decision can properly be filed.
- File the appeal record and submissionsWritten arguments explaining why the decision should not stand.
- Respond to any Ministerial intervention and receive the decisionThe process is mostly document-driven. Do not assume there will be a new hearing at which the story can be retold.
Common grounds of appeal
- Unreasonable credibility findings, or minor inconsistencies treated as decisive
- Failure to consider important evidence, or misunderstanding your testimony
- No fair chance to explain a concern
- Errors in the internal flight alternative or state protection analysis
- Misapplying the refugee definition, or errors about identity, nationality or exclusion
- Procedural unfairness, interpretation problems or inadequate reasons
Credibility appeals
When a claim is refused because the RPD did not believe you, the appeal must do more than say the member was wrong. We look at what finding was made, the evidence behind it, whether the alleged contradiction was real and material, whether you were asked to explain it, whether the explanation was considered, whether corroborating evidence was ignored, whether the finding rested on speculation, whether cultural, psychological or language factors were overlooked, and whether one concern improperly affected the rest of the claim.
New evidence and hearings
The RAD has statutory rules on new evidence (IRPA s.110(4)). A document created or obtained after the refusal is not automatically admissible. The analysis can involve when the evidence arose, whether it was reasonably available before, whether it is credible, relevant and material, and whether it could affect the result. A clear explanation should accompany anything that was not before the RPD.
Most RAD appeals are decided on the written record, with an oral hearing only in limited circumstances. The written appeal therefore has to be complete and well organised. Depending on its findings, the RAD can confirm the RPD decision, set it aside and substitute its own, or send the matter back to the RPD for a new decision.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in refugee appeals. RAD appeals have short deadlines and focus on the record, so we act quickly. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
- Determining whether a RAD appeal is available
- Reviewing the RPD reasons and hearing record
- Identifying factual, legal and fairness errors
- Assessing proposed new evidence and obtaining affidavits
- Preparing the appeal record and written submissions
- Responding to Ministerial intervention and preparing for any hearing
- Advising on judicial review if the RAD dismisses the appeal
What to bring to your consultation
- The RPD decision and reasons, with the date you received them
- Your BOC and the evidence filed at the RPD
- Any hearing recording or transcript you have
- Any new documents you hope to rely on
Questions
Can I stay in Canada during my RAD appeal?
In most cases, removal is stayed while a RAD appeal is pending. A lawyer confirms your situation.
Can I add new documents?
Only evidence that meets the test in section 110(4). A lawyer reviews what may qualify.
Related

Refugee Claims & RPD Hearings
Help making a refugee claim and preparing for your RPD hearing.

Judicial Review of IRB Decisions
Federal Court review of decisions by the divisions of the Immigration and Refugee Board, including the Refugee Protection Division, Refugee Appeal Division, Immigration Division, and Immigration Appeal Division.

PRRA, Pre-Removal Risk Assessment
Applying for protection based on risk before removal from Canada.