Hassana v. Canada, 2026 FC 1355: After Membership, the Fight Moves to the Nexus

Please note: This article is for general information and education only. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create a solicitor-client relationship with Esna Law PC. Immigration law changes often and every case depends on its own facts. Speak with a licensed lawyer about your situation.
A month ago, I wrote about Nahayo and promised a deeper piece on the IRGC conscript cases. The Federal Court has now released another decision on the same issue: Hassana v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2026 FC 1355, decided by Justice Azmudeh on November 4, 2026.
Hassana follows Nahayo and everything before it: Mason applies to all of s. 34, and membership requires a nexus to the security of Canada. Since Ali, the Federal Court has repeatedly pointed out that the Minister is making arguments that have already been addressed. It said so again in Ahamba, Nahayo and now Hassana, and the Federal Court of Appeal said the same in Wahab.
In my view, the law has been clear since Mason, or at least since Ali. The question is whether the Minister will finally come to terms with it. Sooner or later, they will have to. But I think they will simply move the fight over “broad interpretation” from membership to the nexus. Here’s how I see it playing out.
The case
Mr. Hassana is a citizen of Chad who came to Canada in 2019 to claim asylum. The Minister alleged he was inadmissible under s. 34(1)(f) because of his membership in the Patriotic Salvation Movement (PSM) between 2004 and 2015. The Immigration Division agreed, finding that the PSM had engaged in subversion within s. 34(1)(b) and (b.1).
The ID decided the case the way it would have before Mason. It treated the matter as purely factual and never asked whether its finding was consistent with non-refoulement. The Court followed Justice Grammond in Ali, 2025 FC 1682, and Justice Brouwer in Ahamba, 2026 FC 498, and found the decision unreasonable. The matter goes back to a differently constituted panel.
Same arguments, same answer
Frankly, it has been puzzling to watch the Minister show up to these matters, before the Immigration and Refugee Board, the Federal Court and even the Federal Court of Appeal, making the same arguments that have been rejected numerous times, by different decision-makers and at different court levels. Several decisions before Hassana had already confirmed that nearly all of the Minister’s arguments had been disposed of. Yet the Minister kept advancing them.
Hassana is no different. The Minister argued that the ID’s jurisdiction is narrow, that admissibility and removal are distinct, that the ID decides only legal issues, and that applying non-refoulement at this stage would be absurd. The Court rejected all four (paras 32–58), noting that the Minister continues to advance the “safety valve” argument despite Mason rejecting it (para 41). It also declined to certify a question because the issue is settled (paras 68–73).
The issue has never really been the law. It has been, and maybe not for much longer, that the Minister simply doesn’t seem to read the room.
Now, after the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision in Wahab, there seems to have been some realization. Notably, the Minister did appeal Wahab to the Supreme Court of Canada. So at some point, whether after Hassana or a few more decisions, the Minister will have to adapt and accept this interpretation.
But for the many individuals historically caught by the broad interpretation of s. 34, I don’t think that will be the end of the story. Until now, the choke point has been the breadth of membership. The next one will be the nexus.
The next choke point: the nexus itself
Now that a security nexus is the writing on the wall, I expect the Minister to shift their arguments to the nexus itself. Specifically, my concern is that they will treat the nexus as a soft hurdle, as if anything that touches a security concern has a nexus to the security of Canada.
Just a few days ago, in one of my admissibility hearings on a s. 34(1)(f) allegation against a former IRGC conscript, the Minister filed updated submissions after Wahab. Until then, in every post-Mason admissibility hearing we had done involving IRGC conscripts, the Minister either disregarded the post-Mason case law or argued that it didn’t apply.
This was the first time they didn’t do that. Instead, if only very briefly, they argued that the person concerned was an IRGC conscript, and that the IRGC is a terrorist organization that poses a risk to the security of Canada. Notably, they made no reference to the individual’s own role in any threat to Canada. They hung their hat on the organization’s nexus. This was exactly my concern.
I expect this to become the Minister’s broader position: the nexus to the security of Canada must be interpreted very broadly, and even individuals with minor associations with an organization have a sufficient nexus because of the grave nature of the organization.
This will be the next battleground: how we define the nexus, and the tension between the individual’s nexus to the security of Canada and the organization’s.
Why the organization’s status is not enough
In my view, that argument misreads what the courts have said. The nexus is not about the organization alone. It attaches to the specific alleged membership. The question is whether this person’s membership links them to a danger to the security of Canada.
Hassana supports that reading in several places:
- The Court said its approach keeps “the focus” on the applicant rather than on country conditions (para 42).
- It adopted Ali’s concern that the old approach caught people in very large organizations, “such as national armies or political parties,” regardless of their “personal connection to security threats” (para 60).
- It held that an interpretation that does not consider “whether the individual actually poses a danger” is unreasonable (para 60).
If the organization’s designation were enough, none of this would matter. Every conscript would be caught by the organization’s profile, which is exactly the overbreadth Mason was meant to correct.
What does this mean for IRGC conscripts and others caught by s. 34(1)(f)?
We will keep relying on the post-Mason case law on membership, and Hassana is one more decision to put in front of the ID.
But we also need to prepare for the shift, which has already started. The question is becoming: what counts as a nexus to the security of Canada? For conscripts who performed trivial and rudimentary tasks during compelled, time-limited service, the answer has to come from their own role, not the IRGC’s listing. But expect pushback here.
That means building records that show what each person actually did and did not do, and why that service does not make them a danger to Canada. More on that in the IRGC piece I promised, which is coming next.
Related practice areas
General information, not legal advice. Every case is different.