Book a consultation →

Last updated

Immigration Hearings & Appeals

Sponsorship Appeals

Appealing a refused family sponsorship to the Immigration Appeal Division.

What is a sponsorship appeal?

If IRCC refuses a family class application, such as a spouse, partner, child or parent, the sponsor can often appeal to the IAD. The IAD is an independent tribunal. It holds a new hearing, so it is not limited to what the officer saw. It can look at the evidence as it stands on the day of the hearing.

Here are the typical refusal grounds we see in these appeals:

  • The officer found the relationship was not genuine or was entered into mainly for immigration purposes
  • A finding of misrepresentation
  • The sponsor or the family member was found not to meet the eligibility requirements
  • An adopted child or dependent child did not meet the legal definition
  • A question about whether the person qualifies as a family class member at all

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

Who can appeal, and what the IAD can consider

The appeal belongs to the sponsor, not to the family member abroad. Some refusals cannot be appealed. There is generally no appeal where the family member was found inadmissible for serious criminality, organized criminality, security reasons or human or international rights violations. A misrepresentation finding can be appealed only where the person you sponsored is your spouse, common-law partner or child.

The IAD can allow an appeal if the refusal was wrong in law, wrong in fact, or wrong in a mix of the two, or if a principle of natural justice was not followed. It can also consider humanitarian and compassionate reasons, including the best interests of any child affected.

Do not forget: in a family class appeal, the IAD can only consider humanitarian reasons after it first decides that the family member is a member of the family class and that you are a valid sponsor. If the refusal was because the relationship was not found to be genuine, that is the point we have to win first.

The process, start to finish

1
Notice of appeal

The sponsor files a notice of appeal with the IAD, on the correct form, and sends the refusal letter. In practice, a copy goes to the registry office responsible for your region.

2
The appeal record

The visa office prepares the record: the refused application, the sponsor’s application and undertaking, other relevant documents and the written reasons for refusal. It is due within 60 days after the Minister receives the notice. If it is late, the IAD can ask the Minister to explain and can move forward with a partial record.

3
Evidence and disclosure

You gather your documents and decide who will testify. Documents must be shared with the other side before the hearing, and a document that is not disclosed on time may not be allowed at the hearing unless the IAD permits it. Disclosure deadlines differ depending on the type of appeal, and generally fall within 30 to 60 days. We confirm the exact deadline for your appeal.

Can the appeal be resolved early?
Early resolution (ADR)

A short, confidential meeting with a neutral IAD facilitator and the Minister’s counsel. If the Minister agrees with your position, the appeal may be allowed on consent, but an IAD member must approve the agreement. You may also withdraw the appeal.

No agreement

The appeal goes to a hearing. What was said at the early resolution meeting is generally kept confidential and does not go on the hearing file.

4
Hearing

The IAD hears the appeal from the beginning (de novo), so it can consider new evidence and the facts as they are at the time of the hearing. You testify, the Minister’s counsel can question you and your witnesses, and each side makes closing arguments. Hearings are usually held by video, and an in-person or hybrid hearing can be requested.

The IAD decides
Appeal allowed

The refusal is set aside and the visa office is told to process the application. In family class appeals, the IAD gives written reasons.

Appeal dismissed

The refusal stands. You can ask the Federal Court to review the decision, but the deadlines are short, and this is a narrow remedy.

Step-by-step detail
  • Forms. There are separate notice of appeal forms for sponsorship, removal order and residency obligation appeals. The wrong form can cause delay.
  • Witnesses. To call a witness other than yourself, we must notify the IAD and the Minister in writing before the hearing, with the witness’s contact details, a summary of the evidence and how long the testimony will take. Expert witnesses need a signed report.
  • Interpreters. If you or a witness needs an interpreter, the IAD must be told the language and dialect in advance.
  • Changing a hearing date. The IAD allows this only in exceptional circumstances, so we ask early and with alternative dates.
  • Private hearings. IAD hearings are generally public. A request to hold one in private must be made in advance and needs a strong reason.
  • Virtual hearings. A person abroad, such as a spouse, can often testify by video or telephone as the IAD directs.

Appeal or start again?

For many refusals, there is a real choice between appealing and filing a new application. The right answer depends on why the application was refused.

Why an appeal can make sense

  • You can bring new evidence that was not before the officer
  • You and your family member can testify and explain
  • The IAD can consider humanitarian reasons, in the right cases
  • Many appeals can be resolved at an early resolution meeting, without a full hearing
  • An appeal can resolve a finding that may follow the family member into future applications

The limits

  • Not every refusal can be appealed
  • If the problem is simple, such as a missing document, a fresh application may be faster
  • The appeal can take time, and the family member usually stays outside Canada while it is pending
  • No one can promise a result, and the IAD decides on the evidence

Do not forget: the time limit to appeal is short and the IAD does not usually extend it. Send us the refusal letter as soon as you receive it, even if you are still deciding what to do.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in sponsorship appeals before the Immigration Appeal Division. An appeal is won by addressing the officer’s concerns, with evidence that is organized, credible and consistent. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

Here is what you can expect from us at each stage of an Immigration Appeal Division appeal.

  1. Deadline and right of appealWe confirm the appeal right, choose the right form and file the notice of appeal on time. We also check whether a new application would be better, or whether both should run together.
  2. Reviewing the recordWhen the appeal record arrives, we compare it with your instructions, note what the other side relies on, check that each statement is supported by evidence, and flag anything that contradicts what you told us.
  3. Building the evidenceThere is time between the notice of appeal and the record, and we use it. We collect your documents, identify gaps, and decide which documents help your case and which could cause harm if disclosed.
  4. Early resolutionWhere the case is suitable, we may ask for an early resolution conference, which is often much shorter than a hearing, or respond if the IAD proposes one.
  5. Preparing you and your witnessesWe prepare you for the questions you will be asked, arrange witnesses and interpreters, make any special requests, such as a private hearing, and meet with you before the hearing so you know what to expect.
  6. The hearingWe question you and your witnesses, respond to the Minister’s counsel and make the closing submissions on the law and the evidence.
  7. After the decisionWe go through the decision with you and advise on next steps, including whether to ask the Federal Court to review it. For that, the deadline is 15 days for applications arising from inside Canada, 60 days for applications arising from outside Canada.

What to bring to your consultation

  • The refusal letter and any officer notes you have
  • Your original application and the sponsor’s undertaking
  • Proof of your relationship over time: photos, messages, travel, money sent, joint documents
  • Letters from family and friends who know the couple
  • Any new documents since the refusal
  • Records of any past immigration applications for you or your family member

Questions

Can my spouse testify from abroad?

Often yes, by phone or video, as the IAD directs. We help arrange this and prepare them in advance.

Should I reapply instead?

Sometimes a new application is the better route, sometimes an appeal is. A lawyer reviews the refusal reasons before you decide.

Do I have to attend the hearing?

Yes. The sponsor must attend. Hearings are usually held by video, and you may ask for another format.

What if the government’s lawyer agrees with us?

Sometimes the Minister’s counsel agrees that the refusal was wrong, often at an early resolution meeting. An IAD member must still approve the agreement.

How much will this cost?

You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment.

What if the appeal is dismissed?

You may be able to ask the Federal Court to review the decision. The deadline is short, so ask us right away. See judicial review of IRB decisions.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about sponsorship appeals.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook