Book a consultation →

Last updated

Immigration Hearings & Appeals

Misrepresentation Appeals

IAD appeals where misrepresentation led to a removal order or a sponsorship refusal.

What is a misrepresentation appeal?

A person can be found inadmissible for misrepresenting or withholding material facts, even if it was by mistake. The finding can lead to a removal order or the refusal of a sponsorship, and can bar a person from Canada for five years. Some people can appeal to the IAD, which holds a new hearing.

Here are the typical situations we handle:

  • A permanent resident facing a removal order based on misrepresentation
  • A sponsor whose spouse, partner or child was refused because of misrepresentation
  • A person who says there was an honest and reasonable mistake, or that the information was not material
  • An error or omission made by a representative or by someone who filled in the forms

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

Who can appeal

Appeal rights depend on who you are and on the decision.

  • Permanent residents can usually appeal a removal order for misrepresentation
  • Other people with a right of appeal may also appeal, depending on their status
  • Sponsors can appeal a misrepresentation refusal only where the person they sponsored is a spouse, partner or child
  • There is no appeal for some other findings, such as those involving serious criminality or security

The process, start to finish

1
Notice of appeal

You file a notice of appeal with the decision or removal order, within the deadline. A copy goes to the right regional registry office.

2
The appeal record

The record is prepared by the Immigration Division, the visa office or the Minister, depending on how the decision was made, and is due within 30 to 60 days after notice.

3
Evidence and disclosure

You gather your documents and decide who will testify. Documents must be shared with the other side before the hearing, and a document that is not disclosed on time may not be allowed at the hearing unless the IAD permits it. Disclosure deadlines differ depending on the type of appeal, and generally fall within 30 to 60 days. We confirm the exact deadline for your appeal.

Can the appeal be resolved early?
Early resolution (ADR)

A short, confidential meeting with a neutral IAD facilitator and the Minister’s counsel. If the Minister agrees with your position, the appeal may be allowed on consent, but an IAD member must approve the agreement. You may also withdraw the appeal.

No agreement

The appeal goes to a hearing. What was said at the early resolution meeting is generally kept confidential and does not go on the hearing file.

4
Hearing

The IAD hears the appeal from the beginning (de novo), so it can consider new evidence and the facts as they are at the time of the hearing. You testify, the Minister’s counsel can question you and your witnesses, and each side makes closing arguments. Hearings are usually held by video, and an in-person or hybrid hearing can be requested.

The IAD decides
Appeal allowed

The finding or order is set aside. In a removal order appeal, the IAD may instead stay the order on conditions.

Appeal dismissed

The decision stands. You may be able to ask the Federal Court to review it, but the deadline is short.

What the IAD looks at

  • Was the finding correct? Was there a misrepresentation or a failure to disclose, was it material, and does an honest and reasonable mistake apply?
  • Humanitarian and compassionate reasons. Even if the finding was right, the IAD may still consider how serious the misrepresentation was, why it happened, your establishment in Canada, the effect on your family, the best interests of children and the hardship you would face.

The IAD can allow the appeal, which sets aside the finding or the order, or dismiss it, which upholds the decision.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in misrepresentation appeals. These depend on the facts and the evidence, so we prepare the record carefully. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

Here is what you can expect from us at each stage of an Immigration Appeal Division appeal.

  1. Deadline and right of appealWe confirm the appeal right and file the notice of appeal within the deadline. We also review the procedural fairness letter and the earlier decision for errors.
  2. Reviewing the recordWhen the appeal record arrives, we compare it with your instructions, note what the other side relies on, check that each statement is supported by evidence, and flag anything that contradicts what you told us.
  3. Building the evidenceThere is time between the notice of appeal and the record, and we use it. We collect your documents, identify gaps, and decide which documents help your case and which could cause harm if disclosed.
  4. Early resolutionWhere the case is suitable, we may ask for an early resolution conference, which is often much shorter than a hearing, or respond if the IAD proposes one.
  5. Preparing you and your witnessesWe prepare you for the questions you will be asked, arrange witnesses and interpreters, make any special requests, such as a private hearing, and meet with you before the hearing so you know what to expect.
  6. The hearingWe question you and your witnesses, respond to the Minister’s counsel and make the closing submissions on the law and the evidence.
  7. After the decisionWe go through the decision with you and advise on next steps, including whether to ask the Federal Court to review it. For that, the deadline is 15 days for applications arising from inside Canada, 60 days for applications arising from outside Canada.

What to bring to your consultation

  • The decision letter, any procedural fairness letter and your reply to it
  • The application forms you submitted, and the file from any representative
  • Documents that explain the error or omission and show what the truth was
  • Evidence of family ties and life in Canada
  • Any records of conversations with a consultant or form-filler

Questions

What if a consultant filled out my forms?

You are usually still responsible for what was submitted, though the circumstances can matter. A lawyer reviews the facts.

How long does the bar last?

Generally five years.

Does an appeal mean I will be allowed to stay?

Not automatically. The IAD decides on the evidence, and we advise you honestly about the strengths and the weaknesses.

What if the appeal is dismissed?

You may be able to ask the Federal Court to review the decision. The deadline is short. See judicial review of IRB decisions.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about misrepresentation appeals.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook