Book a consultation →

Last updated

Immigration Hearings & Appeals

Minister’s Appeals

Responding when the Minister appeals an Immigration Division decision in your favour.

What is a Minister’s appeal?

If the Immigration Division decides at an admissibility hearing that you are not inadmissible, or decides not to issue a removal order, the Minister of Public Safety can appeal that decision to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD). You become the respondent and have to defend the decision you won.

Here are the typical situations we handle:

  • The Immigration Division found you were not inadmissible, and the Minister appeals
  • The Immigration Division made a decision on a removal order, and the Minister disagrees
  • A permanent resident with a criminal record who is defending a decision to let them remain

This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.

What the IAD can consider

The IAD holds a new hearing, so it can hear fresh evidence and is not limited to what the Immigration Division saw. In a Minister’s appeal, the IAD looks at whether the earlier decision was wrong in law, fact, or both, or whether a principle of natural justice was not followed. Unlike other appeals, it does not consider humanitarian and compassionate reasons when the Minister is the one appealing.

The outcome could include a removal order, so a Minister’s appeal needs to be taken seriously.

The process, start to finish

1
Notice of appeal

The Minister serves a notice of appeal on you, on the Immigration Division and on the IAD, within 30 days of the Immigration Division decision.

2
The appeal record

The Immigration Division prepares the record: the removal order, if any, the transcript, the documents accepted as evidence and the written reasons. It is due within 30 days after the Immigration Division receives the notice.

3
Evidence and disclosure

You gather your documents and decide who will testify. Documents must be shared with the other side before the hearing, and a document that is not disclosed on time may not be allowed at the hearing unless the IAD permits it. Disclosure deadlines differ depending on the type of appeal, and generally fall within 30 to 60 days. We confirm the exact deadline for your appeal.

4
Hearing

The IAD hears the appeal from the beginning (de novo), so it can consider new evidence and the facts as they are at the time of the hearing. You testify, the Minister’s counsel can question you and your witnesses, and each side makes closing arguments. Hearings are usually held by video, and an in-person or hybrid hearing can be requested.

The IAD decides
Minister’s appeal dismissed

The Immigration Division decision stands.

Minister’s appeal allowed

The IAD replaces the earlier decision, which can include a removal order.

Weighing the decision

  • You have to take part. If you do not respond or appear, the IAD may decide without hearing from you.
  • The case is not over. The Minister’s counsel will question you and your witnesses and argue that the first decision was wrong.
  • Fresh evidence helps. Since the hearing starts over, we use this time to strengthen the evidence.

Do not forget: the humanitarian grounds are not open to you in a Minister’s appeal, so the case depends on defending the original decision and the evidence behind it.

How we help

We regularly represent clients in Minister’s appeals at the Immigration Appeal Division. These need careful evidence and preparation, so we start by reviewing the earlier decision and the Minister’s grounds. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.

Here is what you can expect from us at each stage of an Immigration Appeal Division appeal.

  1. Deadline and right of appealWe review the Minister’s notice of appeal and the earlier decision right away and confirm what you need to file and when.
  2. Reviewing the recordWhen the appeal record arrives, we compare it with your instructions, note what the other side relies on, check that each statement is supported by evidence, and flag anything that contradicts what you told us.
  3. Building the evidenceThere is time between the notice of appeal and the record, and we use it. We collect your documents, identify gaps, and decide which documents help your case and which could cause harm if disclosed.
  4. Preparing you and your witnessesWe prepare you for the questions you will be asked, arrange witnesses and interpreters, make any special requests, such as a private hearing, and meet with you before the hearing so you know what to expect.
  5. The hearingWe question you and your witnesses, respond to the Minister’s counsel and make the closing submissions on the law and the evidence.
  6. After the decisionWe go through the decision with you and advise on next steps, including whether to ask the Federal Court to review it. For that, the deadline is 15 days for applications arising from inside Canada, 60 days for applications arising from outside Canada.

What to bring to your consultation

  • The Minister’s notice of appeal
  • The Immigration Division decision, reasons and any transcript
  • Your status documents and passport
  • The documents you used at the original hearing
  • New evidence about your circumstances since the first hearing

Questions

Do I have to participate?

Yes. If you do not respond or appear, the IAD may decide without hearing from you.

Can the IAD consider new facts?

The IAD can usually hear fresh evidence. A lawyer reviews what would help your case.

Can the IAD consider humanitarian reasons?

Generally not in an appeal brought by the Minister.

What if the Minister wins?

You may be able to ask the Federal Court to review the decision. The deadline is short. See judicial review of IRB decisions.

Related

Talk to a lawyer about minister’s appeals.

A confidential first conversation, and a straight answer about your options.

CallBook