What is immigration detention?
The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) can detain a permanent resident or foreign national for immigration reasons. When it does, an independent tribunal, the Immigration Division (ID) of the Immigration and Refugee Board, must review the detention at regular hearings. At each one, a member decides whether the person should stay in detention or be released, and on what conditions.
Canadian law treats immigration detention as an exceptional measure. The member must order release unless the Minister proves a legal reason to keep the person detained. Detention and any conditions of release have to be reasonable, necessary and proportionate.
Here are the typical situations we handle:
- Detention on arrival at an airport or border crossing
- Detention after a CBSA arrest, interview or missed appointment
- Detention pending removal from Canada
- Detention after a criminal sentence or parole
- Long-term detention, including where removal has stalled
- Detention of parents with children, and of vulnerable people
This is general information only, not legal advice. Every case is different. Please get independent legal advice about your own situation before deciding what to do.
Who is involved
- CBSA. The officers who detain, and the Minister’s counsel (a hearings officer) who argues for continued detention.
- The Immigration Division member. The independent decision-maker who hears both sides and decides on release.
- You and your lawyer. You can give evidence, call witnesses and answer the Minister’s case.
- A bondsperson. Often a family member or friend who promises money and helps make sure release conditions are followed.
- An interpreter, if you need one, and a designated representative for anyone under 18 or unable to understand the proceedings.
Why someone can be detained
The member must release the person unless the Minister proves, on a balance of probabilities, at least one of these grounds:
- Danger to the public. Usually based on a criminal record or associations. The member looks at present and future danger, how serious and how recent the conduct was, and what has changed since, such as treatment or rehabilitation.
- Unlikely to appear. The concern that the person will not show up for an examination, a hearing or removal. Past non-compliance and weak ties in Canada are considered in context, not automatically.
- An ongoing inadmissibility investigation. The Minister is taking necessary steps to look into a reasonable suspicion of security, human rights, criminality or organized criminality concerns.
- Identity not established. The Minister believes identity can still be established, and the person has not reasonably cooperated, or the Minister is making reasonable efforts.
Proving a ground is not the end of it. Even when a ground exists, the member must weigh other factors before keeping someone detained, including how long the person has been held, how long detention is likely to last, any unexplained delays, the alternatives to detention, and the best interests of any child affected.
The law in brief
- Section 58 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act sets out the grounds for detention and the duty to release.
- Section 57 sets the review schedule.
- Part 14 of the Regulations, including section 248, lists the factors the member must consider before continuing detention.
- Chairperson’s Guideline 2: Detention guides members on how to apply the law, including the Charter.
The process, start to finish
CBSA detains the person and gives the reasons. The person can contact a lawyer and family.
The member hears from the Minister’s counsel and from the detained person or their lawyer. A release plan can be presented at this first hearing.
Where needed, the plan sets out an address, a bondsperson, reporting and other conditions that answer the specific concern.
The person is released, often on conditions, and sometimes with a deposit or guarantee from a bondsperson.
The member gives reasons, including why the alternatives offered were not enough.
A new review within 7 days, then at least every 30 days. Each one is a fresh look at the case.
An early review can be requested when something changes. A decision can also be challenged in the Federal Court.
Step-by-step detail
- Disclosure. The Minister must share all relevant information about the person, not just what it plans to rely on, including information that helps the person. This covers the grounds, removal efforts and contact with the receiving country.
- Evidence. Both sides can present documents and witnesses and question the other side’s witnesses. A CBSA officer can be summoned to answer questions.
- Where and how. Reviews are held at immigration holding centres, jails, IRB offices or by video. Most are public, but they are private if a refugee claim or a risk assessment is pending.
- The decision. Usually given the same day, with reasons that explain which grounds and factors the member relied on.
Release and conditions
Release with minimum conditions, and no deposit or guarantee, should be the first option the member considers. More conditions are added only where they are needed to manage a specific risk. Each condition has to connect to the reason for detention and be something the person can actually meet.
Where conditions are imposed, they usually include living at a stated address and telling CBSA before moving. Depending on the risk, others may be added.
Examples of release conditions
- Reporting to CBSA in person or by phone
- Appearing when required, including for removal
- A deposit or a guarantee from a bondsperson
- Living with a bondsperson or at a set address
- A curfew, or staying within an area
- Not contacting certain people
- Not committing offences, and reporting any charges
- Following parole or court conditions
- Treatment for addiction or mental health, where relevant
- Electronic monitoring, only in exceptional cases
No family in Canada? Release can still be possible. Community organizations, faith groups and supervision programs, including CBSA’s own alternatives to detention program, can sometimes take the place of a bondsperson.
The bondsperson
A bondsperson is often the key to release. When one is available, the member hears from them directly, usually by having them testify. The member looks at:
- How long they have known the person, and their relationship
- Whether they know the person’s immigration and criminal history
- Whether they can supervise and influence the person to comply
- Whether they have been a bondsperson before, and how it went
- Whether the amount is fair given their finances, and what losing it would mean for them
A deposit is money paid up front. A guarantee is a promise to pay if conditions are broken. If the conditions are broken, the money can be forfeited. A bondsperson can later ask to be removed, and either side can ask to change the conditions.
When detention goes on
Detention cannot be indefinite. The Minister has to justify detention again at every review, and that burden gets heavier the longer the person is held. Each member must take a fresh look at the evidence rather than simply repeat the last decision.
- Removal must be realistic. Where detention is for removal, the possibility of removal has to be grounded in the evidence, not speculation.
- Non-cooperation alone is not enough. Even where the person has not cooperated, the member must still weigh all of the factors.
- Conditions of detention matter. Harsh or disproportionate conditions can be a reason to release.
- Alternatives must be looked at again. A release plan rejected before can be reconsidered later.
Do not wait for the next scheduled review. If a new bondsperson, a place in a program, or a change in removal plans comes up, ask for an early review.
Children and vulnerable people
Children are detained only as a last resort and for the shortest time possible. The best interests of any child affected must be considered, whether the child is detained, housed with a parent, or living elsewhere and depending on the detained parent.
For people with mental illness, survivors of torture or violence, elderly people and others who are vulnerable, the member has a heightened duty to consider alternatives to detention and may make procedural accommodations so the person can present their case. A diagnosis is not required for a vulnerability to be taken into account.
How we help
We regularly represent clients in detention reviews. Detention is urgent. The first hearing comes within days, and a practical release plan has to be ready when it does, so we move immediately and assign more than one lawyer where needed. Our team knows what these matters require and has the experience to prepare them carefully.
- Getting the reasons for detention and the Minister’s disclosure, and asking for anything missing
- Identifying the ground the Minister relies on and testing the evidence for it
- Finding and preparing a suitable bondsperson, including for their testimony
- Building a release plan that answers the specific concern, with housing, reporting, treatment or a community program
- Raising vulnerabilities, children’s interests and the length of detention
- Presenting the case at each review, and asking for early reviews when things change
- Challenging long or unjustified detention, including in the Federal Court where a decision appears unreasonable
- Working in parallel on the underlying immigration matter, such as a stay of removal or an appeal
What to bring
- The detained person’s full name, date of birth and UCI or CBSA client number
- Where the person is being held
- Any detention papers, notices or decisions from CBSA or the Immigration Division
- Identity and immigration documents, if available
- For each possible bondsperson: identification, proof of status in Canada, proof of income or assets, and how they know the person
- Proof of the address where the person would live
- Medical or mental health records, if relevant
- Criminal court, sentencing or parole documents, if relevant
Questions
How soon is the first hearing?
Usually within 48 hours of detention. If the person is released before then, there may be no review.
Does the detained person have to prove they should be released?
No. The Minister has to prove that detention is justified. In practice, though, a solid release plan and good evidence are often what make release possible.
Can family members attend?
Most detention reviews are public, but they are private when a refugee claim or risk assessment is pending. A bondsperson is usually asked to testify, and we prepare them for it.
How much money does a bondsperson need?
There is no fixed amount. The deposit or guarantee has to match the risk and be fair given the bondsperson’s finances. Sometimes no money is required at all.
What if there is no family in Canada?
Release can still be possible through community organizations or supervision programs. We look for options early.
What if detention continues?
It is reviewed again within 7 days, then at least every 30 days. An early review can be requested if something changes, and some decisions can be challenged in the Federal Court.
How much will this cost?
You can get an approximate fee through our online consultation portal before your appointment. Detention is urgent, so call us directly if someone has been detained.


