Book a consultation →
Home/Blog/Federal Court
Federal Court · Published December 4, 2025 · 4 min read

How the Federal Court Reviews Canada Visa Decisions

Esna Law PC
Two lawyers reviewing a file at a desk with law books

Judicial review at the Federal Court of Canada can be an effective remedy when IRCC rejects a visa application in an unfair or irrational manner. Judicial review (JR) challenges the refusal’s legality, fairness, and reasonableness rather than appealing the ruling or presenting fresh evidence.

This article explains how judicial review operates, including the steps, deadlines and what to expect.

This article follows on from our guide to visa refusal options, which is a useful starting point.

When judicial review may be appropriate

JR might be suitable in the following situations:

  • Inaccurate or unsupported factual conclusions
  • Ignoring important evidence
  • Generic reasoning without a logical chain of analysis
  • Credibility issues without providing an opportunity for the applicant to reply
  • Misuse of immigration laws or regulations
  • Violations of procedural justice

GCMS notes are important because the quality of the reasons is crucial.

There is a strict deadline.

An application must be filed within 15 days for decisions made in Canada, and within 60 days for decisions made outside Canada.

The parties

1. The applicant

The individual contesting the rejection, typically with legal representation.

2. The Department of Justice (DOJ)

Defends the decision made by the visa officer on behalf of the Minister of Immigration.

3. Judges of the Federal Court

There are two phases:

  • Judge of Leave (determines whether the case moves forward)
  • Hearing Judge (determines the outcome)

Step-by-step judicial review process

1. Submitting the Application Notice

This document begins the case, describes the errors, and identifies the refusal.

The applicant has 30 days to perfect the record if the officer’s reasons are available.
In the event that reasons are unavailable, the court asks the IRCC for Rule 9 reasons, and the 30-day period starts as soon as they are received.

2. Preparing the Application Record

This comprises:

  • Evidence in front of the officer
  • Legal argument (argument memo)
  • Affidavits from the applicant, if necessary
  • Necessary Federal Court forms

Litigation lawyers usually handle this extremely technical stage.

3. Respondent’s memorandum (DOJ)

Within 30 days, the DOJ responds, explaining why the decision was reasonable and defending the rejection.

4. Settlement discussions

A settlement can happen at any point during the process.

When the Department of Justice (DOJ) offers a settlement, it usually involves:

  • Withdrawing the original refusal
  • Sending the case back for another review
  • Giving the applicant a chance to submit updated or additional information
  • Not guaranteeing any specific result

Settlements most often take place shortly after the Application Record has been filed.

5. Applicant’s reply

Once the DOJ submits its arguments, the applicant has 10 days to respond. At this point, the focus is on:

  • Clearing up any mistakes in the DOJ’s reasoning
  • Responding to any misunderstandings
  • Reinforcing the applicant’s main points

6. Leave decision

At this stage, a judge steps in to decide if your case should move forward. The big question they ask is: Is there an arguable case here?

  • If the judge says no, that’s it: your refusal stands.
  • But if the judge says yes, then you’re granted “leave,” and the case goes to a full hearing.

7. The hearing

This usually happens about 90 days after leave is granted.

At the hearing:

  • Your lawyers present your case in court.
  • No new evidence is usually allowed, unless there’s a really good reason.
  • The judge focuses on whether the immigration officer made a fair and legal decision.

The possible outcomes are:

  • Dismissed – The original refusal stays.
  • Set aside – The decision gets overturned, and your file goes back to a different officer for a fresh look.

Even if you win, the court doesn’t hand out the visa. They only send it back for a proper re-decision.

Advantages and disadvantages

Advantages

  • If successful, the refusal is set aside and the application is reconsidered.
  • The timeline is usually clear, with set deadlines.
  • You get another shot during re-determination to fix issues.
  • The new officer must take a fresh look at the application.

Disadvantages

  • Deadlines are tight; missing one could end your case.
  • There are legal fees and court filing fees.
  • Winning does not guarantee that the visa will be issued.
  • If there’s no early resolution, the process can take time.
  • A solid legal argument is required, and the case should not be started unprepared.

Redetermination after a successful judicial review

If the court decides in your favour and sets aside the refusal, your file goes back to IRCC—but this time, a new officer takes a look.

The process works as follows:

  • You can send in updated documents or explanations.
  • The new officer must review everything fairly, based on the law.
  • However, they’re also allowed to raise new concerns if they come up.

Submissions at this stage should be clear, well-organized and supported by evidence.

Final thoughts

Judicial review can be an important option where a visa refusal appears unfair or unreasonable. Knowing the steps, legal tests, and timelines can help you figure out if this is the right option for you.

If you are considering this route, speak to a lawyer as soon as possible, as the deadlines are short.

Note: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. If your visa application has been refused, you can book a complimentary 15-minute video consultation using this link.

General information, not legal advice. Every case is different.

CallBook